What is the rent for a studio at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?

Based on recent listing data, rent for a studio at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY ranges from $1,400 to $4,000 per month, with a median of $1,500.

What is the rent for a 1-bedroom at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?

Based on recent listing data, rent for a 1-bedroom at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY ranges from $1,550 to $3,300 per month, with a median of $1,950.

What is the rent for a 2-bedroom at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?

Based on recent listing data, rent for a 2-bedroom at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY ranges from $1,600 to $6,000 per month, with a median of $2,600.

What is the rent for a 3-bedroom at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?

Based on recent listing data, rent for a 3-bedroom at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY ranges from $2,600 to $4,200 per month, with a median of $3,400.

What is the rent for a 4-bedroom at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?

Based on recent listing data, rent for a 4-bedroom at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY ranges from $3,000 to $6,000 per month, with a median of $4,500.

What is the rent for a 5-bedroom at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?

Based on recent listing data, rent for a 5-bedroom at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY is approximately $4,500 per month.

How does rent at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY compare to the neighborhood?

Compared to other buildings in the 11209 zip code: studio rents are about 29% below the neighborhood median.

Is 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY rent stabilized?

Based on available records, 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY is not currently registered as rent stabilized. Rents at this building are likely set at market rate.

When is the cheapest time to rent at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?

Based on historical listing data, October tends to be the most affordable month to sign a lease at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY, while July is typically the most expensive. Timing your move to October could save approximately 16% compared to peak pricing.

Who is the landlord of 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?

The registered owner of 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY is WALSH, MARGARET. You can view their full portfolio of buildings on Lucid Rents.

Is the landlord of 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY a good landlord?

1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY, owned by WALSH, MARGARET, has an overall grade of A (5.0/5) on Lucid Rents. Check tenant reviews for firsthand experiences.

What is the building rating for 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?

1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY has an overall grade of A with a score of 5.0 out of 5 on Lucid Rents. This score is based on violations, complaints, and tenant reviews.

Are there violations or complaints at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?

Yes, 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY has 2 complaints on record. Visit the building page on Lucid Rents to see the full history, including violation classes and complaint types.

Are there eviction filings at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?

Yes, there are 1 eviction record on file for 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY. The most recent was in June 2026. Eviction records are public information sourced from city marshal data.

What amenities does 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY have?

1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY offers 32 amenities including Security, Parking, Swimming Pool, W/d, Sauna, Grill, Pet Friendly, Washer/dryer, and more. View the full amenity list on the building page.

Does 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY allow pets?

1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY lists pet-friendly amenities (Pet Friendly, Pets Allowed). Contact the building management to confirm current pet policies and any breed or size restrictions.

Does 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY have laundry facilities?

Yes, 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY offers laundry amenities: W/d, Washer/dryer, Washer Dryer, Laundry Room.

Does 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY have a doorman or concierge?

1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY offers the following security and access amenities: Security, Doorman, Gated, Surveillance.

What schools are near 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?

There are 1 schools near 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY, including 1 public school, 0 charter schools, 0 private schools. Nearby schools include P.s. 013 M. L. Lindemeyer (4 min walk).

What public transit is near 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?

1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY has 4 transit options nearby. The closest include: bus: BAY ST/SAINT JOHNS AV (S51, S81), 0.07 mi away.

Is 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY safe? What is the crime rate nearby?

The 11209 zip code where 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY is located had 13,360 crime incidents in the past 2 years, including 822 violent crimes, 3,546 property crimes, and 8,992 quality-of-life incidents. Check the neighborhood report card for 11209 for full details.

When was 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY built and how many units does it have?

1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY was built in 1901, has 2 floors, contains 2 total units.

1251 BAY STREET — Rent Intelligence for Bay Ridge, NYC

Bay Ridge · Staten island, NY

Built 19012 floors2 unitsBBL 5028310006

Current rent range

$1,400 – $6,000 / mo

6 bedroom bands tracked · sampled from recent listings

Leave a review

★★★★★0.00 reviews

Verified reviewsWMOwned byWALSH, MARGARET3 bldgs

1251 BAY STREET

Staten island, NY

1251 BAY STREET is a prewar 1901 building, 2 units in Bay Ridge, NYC. Owned by WALSH, MARGARET. Public records show 2 311 complaints on file. Tenant-impact history includes 1 eviction.

HPD violations0last 7 years · class A, B, C

Evictions filed1last 7 years

Tenant reviews0no reviews yet

Rent-stab units—no coverage

Building age125 ybuilt 1901

311 complaints2last 7 years

01 / 10

Rental intelligence.

Neighborhood Median Rent

Staten Island · March 2026

Studio

$1,500/mo

9 listings

1 BR

$1,950/mo

35 listings

2 BR

$2,600/mo

33 listings

3 BR

$3,400/mo

67 listings

4 BR

$4,500/mo

9 listings

5 BR

$4,500/mo

1 listing

Compare this building's listings above against the neighborhood medians.

Seasonal Pattern

Best & worst months to sign a lease

Cheapest

October

Most expensive

July

JFMAMJJASOND

Potential savings: ~16% by timing your move to October.

Rent vs. area median Staten Island

Studio

This building: $1,400 – $4,000

29% belowArea: $2,100

1 BR

This building: $1,550 – $3,300

—Area: —

2 BR

This building: $1,600 – $6,000

—Area: —

3 BR

This building: $2,600 – $4,200

—Area: —

4 BR

This building: $3,000 – $6,000

—Area: —

Units Historic Rent 0 listings

—No dataNo recent listings

Neighborhood Rent Range Staten Island

Studio9 listings

$2,100

$2,100

1 Bed35 listings

$1,950

$1,550 – $3,300

2 Bed33 listings

$2,600

$1,600 – $6,000

3 Bed67 listings

$3,400

$2,600 – $4,200

4 Bed9 listings

$4,500

$3,000 – $6,000

5 Bed1 listing

$4,500

$4,500

Range (P25 – P75)MedianBased on recent listings in Staten Island

01 / 09

Rental intelligence.

01b / 09

Rent trends.

Southwest Brooklyn

Quarterly market rent, 2014–2026 (latest = Q1 2026 forecast)

Asking rent

$1,764

current quarter

Effective rent

—

per bedroom only

YoY change

1.0%

asking, vs 1 yr ago

10-year change

asking, since ~'16

Asking rent per bedroom type — switch tabs to see each with effective (concession-net) rent.

01b / 09

Rent trends.

02 / 10

Neighborhood risks.

within 0.75 mi

33 nearby

within 0.75 mi

Public-safety

shelters, methadone, halfway, sex offenders

24/7 Noise

sirens, construction, schools, rail, avenue traffic

Environmental

brownfields, industrial zones, sanitation

Block-level

311 noise, rats, bedbug history

Sources: NYC DHS · DOB · 311 · DSNY · FDNY · NYS DCJS · NYS DECSee full report

02 / 10

Neighborhood risks.

02 / 10

Violations, 311, & more.

hpd · dob · 311 · acris
last 7 years

Violation & Complaint Trends

Monthly counts over the last 7 years · all data sources

Steady

HPDTop Violations

0 total

No violations
0

311Top Complaints

2 total

Water System
1
PLUMBING
1

DOBTop Filings

0 total

DOB Violations
0

EvictionsEvictions

1 filed

Evictions filed
1

Recent records

Last 7 years

—NO RECORDS—
No HPD records on file in the last 7 years.

See all 0 HPD records

02 / 09

Violations, 311, & more.

03 / 09

What tenants actually say.

04 / 10

Building amenities.

Building Amenities

32 amenities

BUILDING

Doorman
Library
Lobby
Lounge
Wi-fi

OUTDOOR

Swimming Pool
Grill
Rooftop
Pool
Patio
Balcony
Garden
Terrace
Bbq

FITNESS

Sauna
Fitness
Spa
Gym
Fitness Center

PARKING & BIKES

Parking
Garage

LAUNDRY

Washer/dryer
Washer Dryer
Laundry Room

SECURITY

Security
Gated
Surveillance

PET FRIENDLY

Pet Friendly
Pets Allowed

STORAGE

Storage
Storage Room

OTHER

04 / 09

Building amenities.

05 / 10

The landlord.

WALSH, MARGARET

Portfolio of 3 buildings

Portfolio-level grade reflects the landlord's buildings across NYC, weighted by unit count. Individual building grades may differ.

View full landlord profile

buildings

5.0

avg score / 5

portfolio grade

nearby owned

Ownership timeline · this building

ACRIS deeds and regulatory filings

1901Building constructed2 units · 2 floors
nowWALSH, MARGARETOwner of record per HPD registration · manages 3 buildings.

05 / 09

The landlord.

06 / 10

Crime & safety.

11209 · last 12 months

Safety & Crime

Below averageSafety score · last 12 months

NYPD CompStat · updated weekly

LAST 12 MONTHS · 11209

Violent822

Property3,546

Quality-of-life8,992

Total incidents13,360

07 / 10

About this area.

Bay Ridge · 11209

1251 BAY STREET · Staten Island · 40.613° N, -74.065° W

Walk

Transit

Bike

Estimated from nearby transit & amenity data

4 bus stops nearby1 min

1 school nearby4 min

Nearby Transit

BUS

BAY ST/SAINT JOHNS AVS51S81
0.1 mi1 min
BAY ST/HYLAN BLVDS51
0.1 mi2 min
BAY ST/HYLAN BLVDS51
0.1 mi2 min
BAY ST/NEW LNS51
0.1 mi2 min

Nearby Schools & Colleges

PUBLIC SCHOOLS

P.s. 013 M. L. LindemeyerElementary
0.2 mi4 min

The neighborhood

Bay Ridge

Bay Ridge is Brooklyn's quiet, family-oriented stronghold — a strong Norwegian and Arab-American community along Fifth Avenue, excellent Middle Eastern restaurants, stunning views of the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge, and the Shore Road waterfront promenade.

30,555buildings tracked4.7avg LucidIQ$2,200median 1BR

71,812population$89kmedian income64%renters

Family-FriendlyMulticulturalWaterfrontQuietAffordable

Explore Bay Ridge

Neighborhood overview

Bay Ridge→

Vibe · top buildings · landlords · schools · transit

Crime in 11209

See full breakdown→

Incident type · 6-month trend · vs. New York City average

Rent trends in Bay Ridge

Median rent & comparables→

1BR & 2BR averages · month-over-month · current listings

Nearby neighborhoods to explore

Dyker Heights· 0.83 mi Sunset Park· 1.47 mi Borough Park

Browse all NYC neighborhoods

06 / 10

Crime & safety.

07 / 10

About this area.

08 / 10

History of the building.

construction · ownership · permits

At a glance

Year built1901

Floors2

Total units2

ClassB2

BBL5028310006

19001910192019301940195019601970198019902000201020202030

1901

Building constructed

2 units · 2 floors · class B2

now

Current owner: WALSH, MARGARET

Portfolio includes 3 buildings.

Recent Activity

3 events

EvictionHIGHJun 26, 2026
Eviction Executed — Apt unknown — Possession
311MEDIUMAug 18, 2025
PLUMBING — WATER SUPPLY
311MEDIUMNov 8, 2021
Water System — No Water (WNW)

07 / 09

History of the building.

10 / 10

Frequently asked questions.

What is the rent for a studio at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?
Based on recent listing data, rent for a studio at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY ranges from $1,400 to $4,000 per month, with a median of $1,500.
What is the rent for a 1-bedroom at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?
Based on recent listing data, rent for a 1-bedroom at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY ranges from $1,550 to $3,300 per month, with a median of $1,950.
What is the rent for a 2-bedroom at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?
Based on recent listing data, rent for a 2-bedroom at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY ranges from $1,600 to $6,000 per month, with a median of $2,600.
What is the rent for a 3-bedroom at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?
Based on recent listing data, rent for a 3-bedroom at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY ranges from $2,600 to $4,200 per month, with a median of $3,400.
What is the rent for a 4-bedroom at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?
Based on recent listing data, rent for a 4-bedroom at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY ranges from $3,000 to $6,000 per month, with a median of $4,500.
What is the rent for a 5-bedroom at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?
Based on recent listing data, rent for a 5-bedroom at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY is approximately $4,500 per month.
How does rent at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY compare to the neighborhood?
Compared to other buildings in the 11209 zip code: studio rents are about 29% below the neighborhood median.
Is 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY rent stabilized?
Based on available records, 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY is not currently registered as rent stabilized. Rents at this building are likely set at market rate.
When is the cheapest time to rent at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?
Based on historical listing data, October tends to be the most affordable month to sign a lease at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY, while July is typically the most expensive. Timing your move to October could save approximately 16% compared to peak pricing.
Who is the landlord of 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?
The registered owner of 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY is WALSH, MARGARET. You can view their full portfolio of buildings on Lucid Rents.
Is the landlord of 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY a good landlord?
1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY, owned by WALSH, MARGARET, has an overall grade of A (5.0/5) on Lucid Rents. Check tenant reviews for firsthand experiences.
What is the building rating for 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?
1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY has an overall grade of A with a score of 5.0 out of 5 on Lucid Rents. This score is based on violations, complaints, and tenant reviews.
Are there violations or complaints at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?
Yes, 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY has 2 complaints on record. Visit the building page on Lucid Rents to see the full history, including violation classes and complaint types.
Are there eviction filings at 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?
Yes, there are 1 eviction record on file for 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY. The most recent was in June 2026. Eviction records are public information sourced from city marshal data.
What amenities does 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY have?
1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY offers 32 amenities including Security, Parking, Swimming Pool, W/d, Sauna, Grill, Pet Friendly, Washer/dryer, and more. View the full amenity list on the building page.
Does 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY allow pets?
1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY lists pet-friendly amenities (Pet Friendly, Pets Allowed). Contact the building management to confirm current pet policies and any breed or size restrictions.
Does 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY have laundry facilities?
Yes, 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY offers laundry amenities: W/d, Washer/dryer, Washer Dryer, Laundry Room.
Does 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY have a doorman or concierge?
1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY offers the following security and access amenities: Security, Doorman, Gated, Surveillance.
What schools are near 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?
There are 1 schools near 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY, including 1 public school, 0 charter schools, 0 private schools. Nearby schools include P.s. 013 M. L. Lindemeyer (4 min walk).
What public transit is near 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY?
1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY has 4 transit options nearby. The closest include: bus: BAY ST/SAINT JOHNS AV (S51, S81), 0.07 mi away.
Is 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY safe? What is the crime rate nearby?
The 11209 zip code where 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY is located had 13,360 crime incidents in the past 2 years, including 822 violent crimes, 3,546 property crimes, and 8,992 quality-of-life incidents. Check the neighborhood report card for 11209 for full details.
When was 1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY built and how many units does it have?
1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY was built in 1901, has 2 floors, contains 2 total units.

09 / 09

Frequently asked questions.

09 / 10

Similar buildings nearby.

321 OVINGTON AVENUE

321 OVINGTON AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11209

BrooklynBuilt 1928

View building

8501 FT HAMILTON PARKWAY

8501 FT HAMILTON PARKWAY, Brooklyn, NY, 11209

BrooklynBuilt 1927

View building

6902 RIDGE BOULEVARD

6902 RIDGE BOULEVARD, Brooklyn, NY, 11209

BrooklynBuilt 1922

View building

8517 3 AVENUE

8517 3 AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11209

BrooklynBuilt 1927

View building

08 / 09

Similar buildings nearby.

Embed this building’s record

Drop this scorecard into a tenant guide, blog post, or wiki. It updates itself as new violations are filed.

<iframe src="https://lucidrents.com/embed/building/90c1f312-49ff-4742-9160-c60908469a47" width="100%" height="220" style="border:1px solid #e2e8f0;border-radius:12px" title="1251 BAY STREET, Staten island, NY — LucidRents building record" loading="lazy"></iframe>

Building record last updated September 30, 2026. Sourced from HPD, DOB, 311, and Lucid Rents data syncs.