Monthly Rent Report

Sheepshead Bay Rent Report — September 2025

Asking rents in ZIP 11229, New York City, from 83 listings.

Median 1BR rent in Sheepshead Bay was $2,095 in September 2025, down 19.3% (−$502) from August 2025 and up 23.2% year-over-year. The middle half of 1BR listings asked between $2,000 and $2,400. That puts Sheepshead Bay $687 below the New York City citywide 1BR median of $2,782. The month's figures are based on 83 listings across 10 bedroom categories.

Median Rent by Bedroom Count

BedroomsMedianVs. August 2025Vs. September 2024P25–P75 RangeListings
Studio$5,000+$3,200 (+177.8%)+$3,000 (+150.0%)$1,850 – $5,50011
Studio$1,921+$121 (+6.7%)−$79 (-4.0%)$1,075 – $3,46111
1BR$2,095−$502 (-19.3%)+$395 (+23.2%)$2,000 – $2,4009
1BR$1,950−$647 (-24.9%)+$250 (+14.7%)$1,910 – $1,9987
2BR$3,254+$404 (+14.2%)+$604 (+22.8%)$3,025 – $3,56414
2BR$2,700−$150 (-5.3%)+$50 (+1.9%)$2,700 – $2,7002
3BR$3,400+$100 (+3.0%)−$95 (-2.7%)$2,988 – $3,87510
3BR$3,400+$100 (+3.0%)−$95 (-2.7%)$2,850 – $3,87516

Median, P25, and P75 are asking rents from listings posted in September 2025. Changes compare against the nearest prior month with data.

Sheepshead Bay vs. New York City — September 2025

BedroomsSheepshead Bay MedianNYC Citywide MedianDifference
Studio$5,000$2,825+$2,175 (+77.0%)
Studio$1,921$2,825−$904 (-32.0%)
1BR$2,095$2,782−$687 (-24.7%)
1BR$1,950$2,782−$832 (-29.9%)
2BR$3,254$3,300−$46 (-1.4%)
2BR$2,700$3,300−$600 (-18.2%)
3BR$3,400$3,794−$394 (-10.4%)
3BR$3,400$3,794−$394 (-10.4%)

Citywide figure is the median of zip-level medians across 175 New York City zip codes with listings in September 2025.

Advertisement