Back to WHITEHALL PROPERTIES, LLC

All 23 tenant reviews.

WHITEHALL PROPERTIES, LLC · avg 4.5 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Jan 2026

Pros: Great location, responsive staff, minimal maintenance issues, nice size units, updated, big windows Cons: A little noisy, steep rent increases, can’t use the grill on the roof

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★Nov 2025

Pros: responsive mgmt. always clean Cons: very strict. will give noise complaints for little things but have music blasting on roof at 9pm on a tuesday

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Jul 2025

Unit 617 Pros: Incredibly well-managed and clean. Unique decor and lovely staff Cons: Staff can be a bit strict with visitors, etc.

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★Mar 2025

Pros: Very clean, nice lobby, staff inside the building are good Cons: Management company was difficult Advice to landlord: No advice

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Jul 2024

Pros: Like living in a hotel, service is very nice Cons: Management doesn't always treat the people who work there well

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★Apr 2024

Pros: Efficient. Well run. Cons: Too strict, rude owners and super

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★Dec 2023

Pros: Very clean good looking building Cons: Too much construction

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Nov 2023

Pros: - expansive ground floor - thick walls - nice bathroom Cons: - loud from outside

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Oct 2023

Unit 516 Pros: Management is super responsive to any maintenance requests. Nest controls for heat/ac are super convenient. Cons: Laundry is really expensive - $3.50 for each wash and again for each dry

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Aug 2023

Unit 821 Pros: Clean Quiet Building staff was great/friendly/helpful Cons: Only allowed 2 extra people per unit on the roof at a time Units facing the courtyard didn’t get much light Moving was a hassle with only certain days/hours allowed and only able to reserve the elevator for 2 hrs Furnishing Apt is a hassle because you have to schedule a time for delivery with the delivery garage and frate elevator even if you don’t know exactly when the item will arrive Advice to landlord: Be a little more lax with moving in/out, it’s stressful enough there’s no need to make it even harder

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★Jul 2023

Unit 710 Pros: clean, attached to gym, excellent location! Cons: they rent to corporate housing and these tenants complain about the smallest thing! Including computers speaker noise Advice to landlord: don't let the corporate tenants irritate regular tenants so much with their little complaints

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Sep 2022

Pros: Well maintained. Excellent staff. Large units. Good amenities. Convenient location. Nice neighbors. Cons: Literally everything about this building is great except for the fact that it’s on 23rd and 6th. Which is easily one of the most crowded / annoying corners to live on in the city. It’s so convenient for getting around but not a nice relaxing place to step outside to

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★Sep 2022

Pros: -clean building with luxe facilities -responsive, friendly, and helpful staff -great location Cons: -Management company is incompetent and unresponsive -took over 1.5 yrs to settle an incorrect balance they were carrying for no reason, and even went as far to send me legal notice -not solutions oriented

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Jul 2022

Pros: Very clean and polite staff! Cons: You can hear when gym goers downstairs drop heavy weights no matter where you are in the building

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★Jul 2022

Unit 700 Pros: The building is in a fantastic location, with excellent staff. Everything is kept very clean. Cons: The staff are extremely stringent and unaccommodating. Moving in and out was made even more stressful due to the artificial constraints of timing and elevator use. Any use of the amenities was also met with headaches on protocols etc. Advice to landlord: Be reasonable

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Jun 2022

Pros: Close to everything, friendly employees, very clean and well maintained Cons: Ridiculous pet policy - no guests can visit with their pet. So in holidays, etc a family member can’t bring their dog.

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Apr 2022

Pros: This property is very well-maintained. You will hardly see a speck of dirt, garbage rooms are emptied regularly, there’s good sound isolation between the units, elevators work and they do appropriate maintenance, and they are very responsive to any maintenance requests. Cons: It is located on a very busy intersection. While this is convenient, there can be a fair amount of street noise. Advice to landlord: Thanks for keeping the property so well-maintained!

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Sep 2021

Pros: Clean, excellent building manager named Jon. Cons: One of the worst landlords in New York. Non responsive, not reasonable and violate both tenants rights and make living here beyond a year an exercise in futility. Having rented here for 10+ years, and been through the process and seen the revolving door. Neighborhood is also a homeless encampment.

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Jul 2021

Pros: On top of their shit! Almost like living in a hotel Cool perks like random breakfasts or rooftop barbecues Cons: Very strict. Absolutely no smoking, you will get called out immediately by management. They watch you like a hawk. If you do something against the rules, they’ll be sure to let you know Advice to landlord: Move here if you like great service and if you are not a smoker

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★Jul 2021

Pros: Big beautiful clean spaces. Great views. Cons: Very load construction during the working day. Strict management. Feels like hotel

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★Jul 2021

Pros: Clean, great staff, great appliances, safe Cons: Thin walls, make sure your neighbors don’t have small children or babies or play loud music Floors are slanted on a slight incline Expensive for what it is Washer driers are a 6 min walk from main side of apartment. This is actually annoying. And they’re expensive. Unfortunately lots of homeless in this area Advice to landlord: Take noise complaints seriously

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Dec 2020

Pros: Great staff, professional management, very clean Cons: No cons noted Advice to landlord: Building is great

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Aug 2020

Pros: The building is clean, the people are nice, and my kids have an area to play. Cons: I wish the rec areas were open, but due to COVID guidelines I understand why they can’t be. Advice to landlord: Keep up the great work, I always get immediate responses when I have issues.

56 WEST 23 STREET · Manhattan
Advertisement