Back to MAY REALTY LLC

All 4 tenant reviews.

MAY REALTY LLC · avg 5.0 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Jun 2025

“Pros: Good size apartments, nice neighbors, and good management Cons: Packages have been stolen from time to time, but management did help”

— 47 MAUJER STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Jul 2022

“Unit 2 Pros: Responsive landlord and lovely super, problems were fixed quickly even when they came up on holidays. Never had any pest problems, despite living in a basement apartment. Cons: Would have stayed with the rental company when I moved if they were a little more affordable - I had taken over a lease and prices for smaller units were pretty high when I was looking but that's just a NYC problem. Advice to landlord: I've never had such a decent landlord, let alone in NY. Keep it up!”

— 186 MESEROLE STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Nov 2020

“Pros: Great location, pet loving landlords, great to have a private courtyard (w/bike storage) and roof deck during quarantine. Dishwasher and HVAC in units, coin laundry room in basement. Building has been lived-in, but maintained. Common areas kept clean by staff. Super is responsive and quick with repairs. Small, family-owned property mgmt office located two doors down. There is a beautiful Japanese shio plum tree behind the property that blossoms and fruits each year. Cons: Some of the finishes in the units are basic or outdated. (A lot of honey oak.) There are a few design flaws- such as the tiled-in toilet paper holder being 50” reach from the seat. The laundry room machines often have issues, which was less annoying when they were cheaper. It’s a walk-up, so upstairs tenants get some flights in. Intercom building, generally feels secure, but having Salerno open 24/7 is kind of nice. One loud, drunk neighbor yells on the phone, is the president of the renter’s association. Even though we don’t have said association. Advice to landlord: Less coins in the laundry. Otherwise, thanks for being great lords of the land.”

— 47 MAUJER STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Sep 2020

“Pros: Great rooftop and yard - excellent super/property manager Cons: Only one washer and dryer for 3 buildings basically Advice to landlord: Add more laundry machines and latch entry”

— 186 MESEROLE STREET · Brooklyn
Advertisement