Back to MANHATTAN VALLEY REAL

All 4 tenant reviews.

MANHATTAN VALLEY REAL · avg 3.3 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Jul 2025

“Unit 4C Pros: Recently renovated, weekly/biweekly cleaning of staircases and stairwells, good super, working with Ethan is easy if you communicate effectively Cons: Buzzing; the entire building gets buzzed when packages are being delivered, creaky floors for the rent stabilized / haven’t moved since late 1900s apartments into our apartment which was renovated.”

— 59 WEST 105 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Apr 2023

“Unit No Pros: Space for Manhattan apartment Cons: Everything else especially the landlord unwillingness to help fix things and his rudeness toward tenants who pay their rent on time and respect his apartment. Also went without heat for several days during the coldest part of 2022 winter. Advice to landlord: Be nice and pay attention to your tenants requests. They are the reason you can be a landlord and get paid!”

— 56 WEST 105 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Nov 2021

“Pros: Building is nice and mostly clean with quiet tenants Cons: Building and amenities are aging without much upkeep.”

— 59 WEST 105 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Sep 2020

“Pros: Close to Central Park Cons: Dirty common areas. Poor cleaning. Rats inside the building. Slow to respond to any service requests. Overpriced Advice to landlord: Clean your building. Fix the rat issue.”

— 59 WEST 105 STREET · Manhattan
Advertisement