Back to MACOMBS REALTY

All 5 tenant reviews.

MACOMBS REALTY · avg 3.2 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★May 2025

“Pros: Super is very responsive and friendly. Is able to help. Neighbors are nice and helpful too, lots of young people. Cons: Mice problem that was very fully addressed. Heating is incredibly loud during the winter and no AC so the summers are sweltering. Small kitchen. Drains keep getting backed up. Water damage. The unit is not in great shape.”

— 28 MACOMBS PLACE · Manhattan
★★★★★Dec 2023

“Pros: I loved living here and the area; lots of space and well heated in the winter. Cons: The super does not respond unless you contact management, then he will get mad at you for contacting them. Difficult to work with.”

— 28 MACOMBS PLACE · Manhattan
★★★★★Jul 2023

“Unit 18 Pros: Cheaper covid discount price Cons: The management is a complete hot mess. They do not communicate, they are all over the place with their records, there were lots of issues with initial apartment with shower , kitchen, stove , etc. Advice to landlord: Get it together.”

— 28 MACOMBS PLACE · Manhattan
★★★★★Jun 2022

“Pros: Very kind and responsive super, always comes quick to fix things Cons: Had mice in our apartment along with later ants, roaches, etc. Nearly every appliance broke at some point. They rekeyed the building with no advance notice.”

— 28 MACOMBS PLACE · Manhattan
★★★★★Aug 2020

“Pros: apes are renovated Cons: hallways are old Advice to landlord: update the common areas”

— 28 MACOMBS PLACE · Manhattan
Advertisement