All 8 tenant reviews.
ESQUIRE GROUP ESTATES LLC · avg 2.4 ★★★★★ · New York City
“Pros: Nice location, friendly neighborhood, laundry room is great. In building gym, key fob access Cons: We caught 8 mice in our one year living here. The hallways were always grimy and smelled like cigarette smoke. The super has several huskies that he lets out in the back alley, they poop everywhere so the back alley is usually infested with flies. The walls were so thin, we could smell the incense our neighbor would light every day, and could hear kids running around in the unit above us.”
— 235 WEST 146 STREET · Manhattan“Pros: Decent rent prices during Covid Cons: rent increased significantly after Covid, reports of tenants being unsafe about maintenance staff in the building.”
— 235 WEST 146 STREET · Manhattan“Pros: Central location to subway. Cons: Super isn’t always responsible. Typical old building problems.”
— 235 WEST 146 STREET · Manhattan“Unit A16 Pros: solid neighborhood, at least the basic stuff works Cons: grime, roaches, thin walls”
— 235 WEST 146 STREET · Manhattan“Pros: New laundry system is good. Interactions with the property management company have actually been surprisingly positive and productive. Cons: Roach infestation on my floor and throughout the property, especially the laundry room. Stairwells have cigarette butts and other litter, never consistently cleaned. Super is unresponsive. The third party rent collection website is terrible. Advice to landlord: Get a new super and rent collection site.”
— 235 WEST 146 STREET · Manhattan“Pros: Separate kitchen and living room. Cons: The stairwell smells like cigarette smoke because tenants sit and smoke in the hallways. The floors are terrible. I can hear and feel the neighbors footsteps from next door to the unit above, while the neighbor across the hall I can hear shouting at their tv. It is a noisy and rickety place since our floor shakes when the neighbors walk or drop things. It feels as though they are in your unit. The public spaces are messy and musty. Advice to landlord: Fix the floors and get a better super, as well as someone to clean the common areas.”
— 235 WEST 146 STREET · Manhattan“Pros: The actual units are pretty well maintained and modern. Appliances are standard and working. Super lives on site and is responsive. Cons: Just generally sort of dark and dirty in the lobby/stairwells. There's a buzz system that is not really programmed but you do need a key fob to go in which is nice. Advice to landlord: More regular deep cleans.”
— 235 WEST 146 STREET · Manhattan“Pros: Good floorplans + close to many transport options Cons: Gets very hot on upper floors, frequent noise at night, not the cleanest builing”
— 235 WEST 146 STREET · Manhattan