Back to BREWSTER 2016 LLC

All 5 tenant reviews.

BREWSTER 2016 LLC · avg 3.2 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★Mar 2026

Pros: Location to the subway and the park Majority of the staff is fabulous, super is great! Neighbors are nice and respectful. Many apartments are updated and have a washer dryer in unit. Cons: There is NOT 24/7 desk coverage. The overnight person calls out a lot, they use a porter to cover desk shifts so they multi task. Often someone isn’t at the desk and the door is open to anyone. Can hear noisy neighbors through the wall. The building doesn’t regulate the 80% carpet rule in all apartments, some issue with noise. Advice to landlord: Pay for temps to work the desk so the building has 24/7 service. Update the lobby, watermark stains down the walls from previous flooding.

21 WEST 86 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★May 2023

Pros: It's a good location. Doormen are nice. Cons: The building is poorly maintained. They will raise your rent beyond the market price. They will be slow to fix things and they will fix things badly. Advice to landlord: Clean the walls in the lobby

21 WEST 86 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★Oct 2022

Pros: Great doormen/staff, amazing location near the park and really nice high end apartments Cons: We had issues with the HVAC that had to be replaced. Better now

21 WEST 86 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Oct 2021

Pros: Renovated apartments in great location Cons: Rodents Slow response time re: repairs Renovations are flawed to rodents, broken HVAC, buckling floors. Advice to landlord: Do something about rodents. Lobby needs fixing. Maintenance staff nice but need actual professionals for repairs. Renovations = lipstick on a pig l

21 WEST 86 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Apr 2021

Pros: Location is quite nice and convenient Cons: Building premises could do with a bit refurbishment

21 WEST 86 STREET · Manhattan
Advertisement