Back to 89TH STREET ASSOCIATES #1, LLC

All 6 tenant reviews.

89TH STREET ASSOCIATES #1, LLC · avg 4.0 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Mar 2026

“Pros: -responsive, live-in super -friendly neighbors -good location Cons: -roach-infested. Super and pest control could not remove or contain the infestation. Multiple neighbors I spoke with had issues.”

— 238 EAST 89 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Dec 2025

“Pros: rent stabilized, amazing response from super Cons: walls are very thin and could smell insane cigarette/ weed smell despite being a non smoker building”

— 236 EAST 89 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Nov 2024

“Unit 4B Pros: Super is responsive, but not very effective Cons: The lawyer who lives in unit 4A has been hoarding for decades, and is physically unable to leave the apartment. Living in disgusting, unsanitary conditions - breeding roaches throughout the whole building. They're literally coming from everywhere; drains, the hallway, electrical outlets/lightswitches, etc. He leaves personal items like cat food and litter in the hallways, creating dangerous fire hazards for every tenant in the building. He leaves his door wide open for no reason at all, other than to let the smell of death and cat urine flow into the hallways. This apartment is a nightmare. There is roach feces underneath all of the surfaces of the kitchen and bathroom and inbetween cabinets. Roach eggs found in the oven and dishwasher (have also been doused with insecticide and are no longer safe to use, but management won't replace). Management refuses to provide cleaning services, and won't act on the neighbor most likely because they're afraid of being sued. Advice to landlord: Scott K. Nigro, Esq., the property owner - stop obsessively posting about politics on social media and learn to treat your tenants like humans beings. If you call yourself a progressive, then act like one.”

— 238 EAST 89 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Sep 2024

“Pros: Basic building, friendly super Cons: Roaches in kitchen”

— 238 EAST 89 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Aug 2023

“Pros: The building is located on a quieter street between larger avenues with access to a lot of great restaurants and stores. The supers are amazing and really do a great job at keeping the building clean and also helping with any issues we have. Cons: The layout of the apartment is a little wonky. The walls are uneven which makes it hard to organize the layout of the apartment.”

— 238 EAST 89 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Apr 2023

“Unit C Pros: Responsive super, quiet street. Cons: Thin walls, package theft.”

— 238 EAST 89 STREET · Manhattan
Advertisement