The Sagamore
Compared to median rents in 10024, Manhattan
No HPD violations on record.
Rent Trend
↑ 18% since 2019
vs. Neighborhood
40% above median
Best Time to Move
Cheapest: June
Based on listing data. Range shows min-max asking rents.
How amenities, location, and building condition affect your rent
Based on listing data
Amenity premiums in this area
Above neighborhood average
Potential savings: ~28% by timing your move
| Type | Price Range |
|---|---|
| Studio | $4,157 – $4,412 |
| 1 Bed | $5,111 – $5,775 |
| 2 Bed | $8,236 – $10,013 |
| Unit | Rent | As Of |
|---|---|---|
| — | $4,284/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $4,277/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $4,277/mo |
| Apr 2026 |
| — | $4,076/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $4,142/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $4,183/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $3,941/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $4,176/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $4,176/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $4,056/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $4,137/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $4,291/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $4,306/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $4,137/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $4,425/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $4,425/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $4,501/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $4,428/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $4,428/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $4,421/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $4,428/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $4,428/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $4,589/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $4,296/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $4,428/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $4,296/mo | Mar 2026 |
| Unit | Rent | As Of |
|---|---|---|
| — | $5,443/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $5,443/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $5,443/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $5,443/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $5,111/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $5,448/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $5,111/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $5,596/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $5,596/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $5,122/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $5,596/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $5,596/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $5,863/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $5,626/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $5,863/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $5,691/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $5,852/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $5,943/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $5,943/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $6,191/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $5,943/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $5,887/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $5,943/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $5,611/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $5,943/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $5,611/mo | Mar 2026 |
| Unit | Rent | As Of |
|---|---|---|
| — | $9,124/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $9,113/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $9,113/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $8,236/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $9,887/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $9,893/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $9,893/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $9,887/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $9,893/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $9,893/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $9,893/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $9,893/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $9,893/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $9,893/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $9,293/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $9,293/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $9,293/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $8,621/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $9,293/mo | Mar 2026 |
| — | $8,621/mo | Mar 2026 |
| Unit | Rent | As Of |
|---|---|---|
| — | $13,993/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $13,993/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $13,993/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $14,050/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $13,993/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $13,993/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $13,993/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $14,050/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $13,993/mo | Apr 2026 |
| — | $13,993/mo | Apr 2026 |
Based on listing data
of tenants recommend
Based on 10 verified reviews
“The Sagamore apartment building is a great place to live. The front door/concierge always greets you with a smile and takes excellent care to make sur”
— Anonymous, May 2024
“I have lived in the Sagamore for 1.5 years, and it is a wonderful place to live! The building is close to Central Park and Riverside Park and is very ”
— Anonymous, Feb 2022
Former Resident 258967
1 years ago
The Sagamore apartment building is a great place to live. The front door/concierge always greets you with a smile and takes excellent care to make sure you get your packages/deliveries. Maintainence/porter staff to excellent care of the building, clean and kept up. Gym is well maintained and has everything you need to work out. Small dog park is easily accessible. Even an indoor play area for the small ones. Lots of machines available in the laundry room. Management staff is super helpful and professional, special mention to Aprell. The neighborhood has everything you need for food shopping and dining within easy walking distance. Pharmacy and Urgent Care center nearby too. Highly recommend.
2 years ago
I was a tenant at The Sagamore for three wonderful years. During that time, the staff was nothing but attentive, kind, welcoming and helpful. Aprell and Kyle in the leasing office were always incredibly helpful, happy and welcoming. They were always very quick to respond to any needs, questions and concerns. The concierge always went above and beyond to ensure residents felt safe and supported. The building was always kept clean and the amenity spaces are truly fantastic. Could not recommend The Sagamore enough!
Former Resident 738795
2 years ago
My experience at the Sagamore was phenomenal. The staff were friendly and supportive, the community was nice, and the amenities really offered a great living experience! The building is also conveniently located in the UWS putting it near the 1 stop and some lovely restaurants. Altogether a great experience; if I hadn't had to move out of the city because of work, I'd still be living there! 10/10
Justin_K648
3 years ago
The Sagamore is an excellent property. Well located, quality GE kitchen appliances, great service, great amenities. The gym is nice and the roof deck is especially nice with communal grills that can be used.
Kathryn_B415
3 years ago
The day that I toured the Sagamore, I felt like I was in a bit of a dream. I'd seen many apartments by that time and most were just passable in appearance, security and amenities. The Sagamore, in comparison, has a lovely entry decorated in a contemporary style and professional concierge to help you with anything you might need. The third floor has several amenities including a HUGE outdoor patio and a private dog run for pet owners, as well as a large air-conditioned laundry room with at least 15 washer and dryers, and a private gym which you can use for a nominal yearly fee. Residents can also use the beautiful rooftop to sit out and enjoy the view. While these are great perks, I have been enjoying my apartment most of all. I've had minimal issues with mechanicals, but each time I've contacted the building, they've fixed the issue within 24 hours. Additionally, I feel very safe in the building. The only issue I've had since moving in is with the sound of sirens as my apartment faces Amsterdam Ave and it is a corridor to 2 hospitals. The sound of regular traffic is actually minimal as the windows are well sealed, but sirens are just another level up noise-wise. The longer I've lived in NYC (just 6 months now) the more I appreciate the location of the Sagamore on the UWS. It's a great area, very close to Central Park and Riverside Park, the subway is just 3 short blocks away, 2 small grocery stores and CVS are 2-3 blocks and Trader Joe's is 4 blocks north on Columbus Ave. Just a little further on 96th St. are Whole Foods, TJ Maxx, Sephora and Target. And there are several great restaurants all along Amsterdam and Columbus. It's really a perfect spot!
4 years ago
My family lives living at the Sagamore! The location is great, with lots of restaurants, playgrounds, parks, and schools nearby. We love the well-kept and up-to-date amenities like the gym, playroom, dog run, courtyard, grills, and rooftop - and use them almost daily! Our apartment is full of light, has a great layout, and modern appliances and fixtures. But what really makes this building feel like home is the incredible friendly and helpful staff. The doormen, maintenance crew, and property management team all go above and beyond to make you feel welcome and to resolve any issues. I live this community and highly recommend it!
marwa_k
4 years ago
I have had two apartments at The Sagamore (studio and now a one-bedroom) and have to say it is the best building and community that I had in my eight years in New York! Other than the apartments being well maintained with amazing sunlight, the staff is super friendly and the management is very courteous and always making an effort to show appreciation for tenants. What I love most about The Sagamore is how fast you get used to living here, after only a few weeks it feels like home. Highly recommended for anyone who is looking for a 'home' in NYC!
Julia_H206
4 years ago
I have lived in the Sagamore for 1.5 years, and it is a wonderful place to live! The building is close to Central Park and Riverside Park and is very well maintained; my individual apartment has modern appliances, beautiful hardwood floors, high ceilings, and plenty of sunlight. The amenities are also great: the rooftop and courtyard are great for hosting guests, the laundry room is clean and always has machines available, and the spacious dog run is my (and my pup’s!) favorite unique amenity. The staff are also very friendly and quick to respond whenever I need assistance. I highly recommend this building!
chemistry_and_coffee
5 years ago
I really enjoy the apartment building (nice fixtures, lots of light even in common spaces, great staff). I also think the management team is professional and excited to work with tennents. Highly recommend.
joanpone
5 years ago
For the last 20 years, The Sagamore and New York City have been my home, and I am grateful for both. The staff here, including office people, front desk folks and maintenance crew, are friendly and always willing to go the extra mile to make my home a place I look forward to curling up in. The entire community, staff and residents, is like family to me, which has been especially comforting during Covid. The building is well maintained, and issues are resolved quickly and satisfactorily. Social activities are welcome and give us the opportunity to get to know our neighbors better -- and chow down on yummy treats. And I couldn't ask for a better neighborhood. Restaurants, shopping, an easy walk to the Hudson River or Central Park. And even closer is the lovely West Side Community Garden. I am happy to be here and happy to share my experience!
21 questions answered
Based on recent listing data, rent for a studio at 189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024 is approximately $4,142 per month.
Based on recent listing data, rent for a studio at 189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024 is approximately $4,291 per month.
Based on recent listing data, rent for a studio at 189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024 ranges from $4,157 to $4,412 per month, with a median of $4,284.
Based on recent listing data, rent for a 1-bedroom at 189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024 is approximately $5,111 per month.
Based on recent listing data, rent for a 1-bedroom at 189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024 is approximately $5,626 per month.
Based on recent listing data, rent for a 1-bedroom at 189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024 ranges from $5,111 to $5,775 per month, with a median of $5,443.
Based on recent listing data, rent for a 2-bedroom at 189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024 ranges from $8,236 to $10,013 per month, with a median of $9,124.
Based on recent listing data, rent for a 2-bedroom at 189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024 is approximately $8,236 per month.
Based on recent listing data, rent for a 3-bedroom at 189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024 is approximately $13,993 per month.
Based on recent listing data, rent for a 3-bedroom at 189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024 is approximately $13,993 per month.
Based on available records, 189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024 is not currently registered as rent stabilized. Rents at this building are likely set at market rate.
The registered owner of 189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024 is STEPHEN GAYNOR SCHOOL. You can view their full portfolio of buildings on Lucid Rents.
189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024, owned by STEPHEN GAYNOR SCHOOL, has an overall grade of C (4.4/10) on Lucid Rents. Tenants have left 25 reviews. Check tenant reviews for firsthand experiences.
189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024 has an overall grade of C with a score of 4.4 out of 10 on Lucid Rents. This score is based on violations, complaints, and tenant reviews.
189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024 offers 11 amenities including Pet Friendly, Fitness Center, Parking, Pets Allowed Cats, Pets Allowed Dogs, Doorman, Elevator, Gym, and more. View the full amenity list on the building page.
189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024 lists pet-friendly amenities (Pet Friendly, Pets Allowed Cats, Pets Allowed Dogs). Contact the building management to confirm current pet policies and any breed or size restrictions.
Yes, 189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024 offers laundry amenities: Laundry Facility.
189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024 offers the following security and access amenities: Doorman.
There are 2 schools near 189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024, including 1 charter school, 1 college. Nearby schools include Success Academy Charter School - Upper West (5 min walk), Bard Grad Ctr For Decorative Arts (5 min walk).
The 10024 zip code where 189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024 is located has 2,233 crime incidents on record. Check the neighborhood report card for 10024 for a full breakdown by crime type.
189 W 89TH ST, Manhattan, NY, 10024 has 10 tenant reviews with an average rating of 4.5 out of 10. 0 out of 10 reviewers would recommend this building.