Monthly Rent Report

Sheepshead Bay Rent Report — May 2025

Asking rents in ZIP 11229, New York City, from 43 listings.

Median 1BR rent in Sheepshead Bay was $2,675 in May 2025, up 37.2% (+$725) from April 2025 and up 57.3% year-over-year. The middle half of 1BR listings asked between $2,511 and $2,898. That puts Sheepshead Bay $166 below the New York City citywide 1BR median of $2,841. The month's figures are based on 43 listings across 11 bedroom categories.

Median Rent by Bedroom Count

BedroomsMedianVs. April 2025Vs. May 2024P25–P75 RangeListings
Studio$1,500−$799 (-34.8%)−$500 (-25.0%)$1,500 – $2,3754
Studio$2,295−$4 (-0.2%)+$295 (+14.8%)$2,196 – $2,4714
1BR$2,675+$725 (+37.2%)+$975 (+57.3%)$2,511 – $2,8984
1BR$2,300+$350 (+17.9%)+$600 (+35.3%)$2,300 – $2,3002
2BR$2,750$0 (0.0%)+$50 (+1.9%)$2,700 – $2,9009
2BR$3,000+$250 (+9.1%)+$300 (+11.1%)$2,995 – $3,0005
3BR$3,150+$50 (+1.6%)−$650 (-17.1%)$3,150 – $3,1501
3BR$3,363+$263 (+8.5%)−$437 (-11.5%)$3,163 – $4,13810
4BR$4,500—+$250 (+5.9%)$4,500 – $4,5002

Median, P25, and P75 are asking rents from listings posted in May 2025. Changes compare against the nearest prior month with data.

Sheepshead Bay vs. New York City — May 2025

BedroomsSheepshead Bay MedianNYC Citywide MedianDifference
Studio$1,500$2,799−$1,299 (-46.4%)
Studio$2,295$2,799−$504 (-18.0%)
1BR$2,675$2,841−$166 (-5.9%)
1BR$2,300$2,841−$541 (-19.0%)
2BR$2,750$3,263−$512 (-15.7%)
2BR$3,000$3,263−$262 (-8.0%)
3BR$3,150$3,777−$627 (-16.6%)
3BR$3,363$3,777−$414 (-11.0%)
4BR$4,500$4,345+$155 (+3.6%)

Citywide figure is the median of zip-level medians across 175 New York City zip codes with listings in May 2025.

Advertisement