Back to WESTSIDE 309 LLC

All 11 tenant reviews.

WESTSIDE 309 LLC · avg 3.4 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★Jun 2025

Unit 1006 Pros: Safe area, responsible super, clean, affordable Cons: I lived in a studio with cockroaches

307 WEST 57 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Jul 2024

Pros: Elevator and mailroom are nice. Garbage gets taken out I think twice a day. The location is great. Cons: In between 2 clubs. One club is open Friday/saturday until 4am. The other club is on random weekdays and is also open super late, probably around 3/4am. A lot of units are very dark hardly any natural light. Occasional roaches

307 WEST 57 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★Apr 2024

Pros: Live in super, in building laundry Cons: Noise, bad lighting Advice to landlord: none

307 WEST 57 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Jan 2024

Pros: Great location, clean, good super Cons: This building is right above TWO clubs. It’s sooo miserable we haven’t been able to get anything done about it through the landlords, clubs and 311. Someone even came and issued a noise violation after so many phone calls and months and nothing changed. There is also constantly construction early mornings and on weekends! Don’t live here!! Advice to landlord: Make the club control the noise issue! Have construction done during the week/work hours

307 WEST 57 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Feb 2023

Pros: Location is super Cons: Roach infestations are an issue. Lack of lobby coverage in the daytime. Lobby has become one big package room with no security. Advice to landlord: Be more accessible .

307 WEST 57 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Nov 2022

Pros: There are 2 elevators, nice finishes in apartments Cons: Bad roach problem. Exterminator came and more roaches appeared days later. One of the elevators is locked all afternoon every afternoon for trash pickup

307 WEST 57 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Oct 2022

Pros: Location above the subway Cons: A lot of cockroaches, older building, very loud on 57th st, slow elevators Advice to landlord: Better exterminator

307 WEST 57 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★Sep 2022

Pros: Great, cute building with a great lobby, great security, packages are taken into the package room in a timely fashion (although sometimes hard to actually retrieve said packages), door men are great (when on duty), 2 elevators, buzzer with video capabilities, apartment has character, large bedroom, great views, love the super lots. Great location by Central Park and major subway lines. Cons: There is an elderly hoarder living in a rent stabilized apt on the 8th floor and apparently she has quite the cockroach infestation that has become everyone else’s problem - especially those on the floors above and below hers (me). They’re German cockroaches (yes, I’ve now become a cockroach expert fighting the war against the infestation in our building / apartment) so I guess I should be grateful that they’re small and not the giant American ones?? I would say we have an “incident” or sighting at least weekly if not every other week. They’ve crawled on my desk during conference calls, in our kitchen cabinets, in our bedroom, and one morning I woke up to one casually trotting across our BED. I have done everything humanly possible to stop / prevent this from happening (plugged every hole imaginable, front door stopper, traps, exterminator every other week, complained to management like it’s my side hustle, you name it, I’ve done it) and still the problem persists. Honestly I really have no complaints about this building aside from this problem and I wish this was disclosed prior to us moving in as I would have reconsidered honestly. I’m constantly terrified house guests will find out about our problem 1 one even crawled into my sisters wine glass once and she sipped it in :) sooo that’s fun. I also detest bugs, especially roaches so Sadly a bottle of raid is always within reach. The exterior windows have never been cleaned since we’ve moved in. It’s a 2 way street so there’s plenty of sirens and horns. Advice to landlord: Can we evict this woman? Force her to clean out her apartment? Fumigate it? Do literally anything to make this stop? This is my only complaint about this building.

307 WEST 57 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★Feb 2022

Pros: Centrally located and near trains and park Cons: Very small space. One draw in the kitchen that opened into a pipe. Right next to a club Advice to landlord: No real advice it works for some people

307 WEST 57 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Jan 2022

Pros: Close to central park and lots of subway lines. Cons: Nightclub venue downstairs (Providence) that cranks the bass late into the night. Street noise can come through windows a lot. Security guards that hold packages are hard to find sometimes

307 WEST 57 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Jan 2022

Pros: Friendly staff and great neighbors Cons: Bugs and lots of them Advice to landlord: Get rid of the bugs

307 WEST 57 STREET · Manhattan
Advertisement