Back to WATERFRONT PLAZA LLC

All 9 tenant reviews.

WATERFRONT PLAZA LLC · avg 3.8 ★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Aug 2025

Pros: nice rooms! nice laundry! nice appliances! nice rooftop! Cons: the only thing i'll say is management is not responsive on weekends and jewish holidays, and even then can be hard to reach if maintenance issues after hours

1333 MYRTLE AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★Jul 2025

Pros: It’s a nice modern building with a fairly responsive management. They go on vacations a lot but if you submit a complaint and then call while they’re there you’ll get a response pretty quick. It’s also really close to the M stop. The train is right outside but it’s not close enough to a bend or a stop to where you’d hear the screeching sound it makes. Plus, the thick walls and triple layered class helps. Also there’s 4 separate W/D in the basement so rarely will you ever not be able to not do your laundry. Cons: Rats will get into the walls, die, and then just get stuck there. This is only a direct problem if you live on the first floor close to the street. The main issue for everyone else is that the stairways can sometimes have a pretty gross smell. Packages go missing. It’s definitely the other tenants. I’ve lost a package only to find the box in the recycling a week later. Not a constant problem but I’d try to get things delivered in blank packaging. Some tenants are hit or miss. Some are amazing and super friendly. Some give off the vibe they just moved from San Francisco and can’t believe you’d dare to make noise in THEIR apartment building. It’s not really a big deal but something to consider. Advice to landlord: Take package theft more seriously

1333 MYRTLE AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★May 2025

Pros: Building is relatively new and has a rooftop and a good location to groceries and coffee shops. Cons: Right in front of above ground train, some pests in the basement, some maintenance tasks are not followed up on unless you keep explicitly reminding them.

1333 MYRTLE AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★Jun 2024

Unit 3B Pros: Management was a little aloof but not malicious which in New York isn’t always a guarantee Cons: Sometimes it was difficult to get a response from management but nothing egregious ever happened Advice to landlord: Could be a little quicker to respond

1333 MYRTLE AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★Jan 2024

Pros: Top floor so we had good sunlight, that's about it Cons: Building management was absolutely horrible. We moved into I think 4A, I can't remember, in 2018 and we're the first people to live there, the four of us thought it was great but it was clearly a fast and cheap build. Things were immediately breaking, water spots from the roof above and we have so many issues with the roof itself and how long it took them to finish. The building management was horrible, the neighbors were loud, stuff was always getting stolen, we lasted two years and I don't know how we did looking back. Run.

1333 MYRTLE AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Sep 2022

Pros: - Space - Amenities - Distance to subways (M, L) Cons: - Thin walls - Thieves living in the building - Greedy, uncaring management company Advice to landlord: They pretty much leave you alone. If you're looking for help, however, you will be hard-pressed to get it - unless it threatens their bottom line. There have been numerous reports of theft in the complex that management chooses to keep out of. You do get an ample amount of space and great facilities though.

1333 MYRTLE AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★May 2021

Pros: Building maintenance is efficient when with repair requests. Cons: Package theft common in the building

1333 MYRTLE AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Jan 2021

Pros: Easy access to the subway. New appliances. Multi supermarkets in the neighborhood. Great small businesses in the neighborhood. Cons: The neighbors are very loud and have extremely loud parties. When complained about the noise the building management didn’t help. The building had two floods in a year. A pipe burst twice. No compensation was given to anyone affected. Rugs, furniture damaged twice. Advice to landlord: No rent reductions during covid.

1333 MYRTLE AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★Jan 2021

Pros: My unit has two outdoor balconies and gorgeous rooftop access (with huge space, couches, a grill, a fridge, and sink) AND a small courtyard. It’s truly a blessing to have so much outdoor access. The apartment gets tons of natural light and we usually leave the lights off all day because the windows are huge. It feels clean and new and the rooms are all pretty good sizes. Windows are REALLY soundproof. We live on the 4th floor directly next to the train and if the window is closed you can hardly hear it pass. Virtual doorman is a really great feature too. And of course the central air and heat that we can control the temperature of ja amazing. I’m always excited to bring people over and show off the space because it’s so nice. Always feel comfortable and safe here. Cons: Management is sometimes difficult to communicate with, sometimes hard to see eye to eye with them, but overall they’re pretty responsive and helpful most of the time. Though the building is beautiful, there are some sloppy design features and cheaply made aspects. You can’t see it, but after living in the space for some time, it’s clear to see where they cut corners and tried to cover it up with aesthetics. Packages are prone to getting stolen because the mail area is directly in view of the front door. Appliances can be unreliable but has not been too much of an issue. Advice to landlord: More flexibility with tenants when issues or charges come up (I was charged $100 to have someone open my door when I was locked out in an emergency- we have keycards so it wasn’t even a locksmith involved. They tapped the door open and left). Also lower the rent, it’s a pandemic!

1333 MYRTLE AVENUE · Brooklyn
Advertisement