All 2 tenant reviews.
W 58 ENTERPRISES GROUP LLC · avg 4.0 ★★★★★ · New York City
“Pros: - great location near Columbus circle - extremely minor pest issues over three years - laundry in basement - rear-facing apartments were quiet - digital doorbell so you can see who is buzz Cons: The new landlord (Oct. 2023) raised rents by a ridiculous amount, to the point where one can presume noncompliance under the Good Cause Eviction law. The landlord also failed to respond to questions about return of security deposits until we threatened to take them to small claims court three weeks after we moved out. They did not have copies of our keys, so we always had to be home to let them in to tour the apartment. They do not have an emergency phone number, everything has to be done through email. The old landlord took ACH payments, the new landlordThere was a carbon monoxide problem that caused the fire department to come out at midnight shut the heat off for the entire building.”
— 444 WEST 58 STREET · Manhattan“Pros: Location is amazing Near several subway lines Super is very responsive Updated kitchen appliances No pests Good heat in the winter Washer/dryer in the building Cons: Lacks natural light if you’re not street facing Noise (across the street from Mt Sinai delivery entrance) Advice to landlord: Have street facing windows be noise cancelling”
— 444 WEST 58 STREET · Manhattan