All 16 tenant reviews.

“Pros: You get an incredible building for decently affordable prices, especially for those living with roommates. The doormen and staff in the building are so wonderful - I’m extremely sad to leave. Cons: Third Avenue and 33rd can be a bit dangerous and loud, so if you’re on a low floor, expect that commotion. Elevators have gone through many ups and downs of repairs and being out of service.”

“Pros: - Good management - Good building - super safe - Doorman = friendly - So close to trader joes Cons: - can be loud at night Advice to landlord: None”

“Pros: Extremely convenient, with Trader Joe’s next door, package room, easy access to the ferry, and overall clean, bright apartment Cons: They were doing work on the balconies when I lived there, which was unfortunate and they had scaffolding up.”

“Pros: Management, doormen, maintenance Cons: Elevators are down often Advice to landlord: I have none”

“Unit 10A Pros: safety, amenities, newly renovated, accessibility Cons: I just didn’t love the location of this building Advice to landlord: Nothing”

“Pros: good size units and quick elevators usually, laundry room never too busy Cons: insulation wasn’t great, in the super cold days my apartment was still chilly with the heat on, I felt a draft by the windows”

“Pros: Great building with great management. Cons: Can be loud”

“Unit 2J Pros: I was in a large unit for a very affordable price. There is a gym in the building, a door man, and a portal for all apartment-related issues. Unit was renovated prior to move in. Central AC, dishwasher, laundry in building. Cons: We had a massive pest issue in our unit and it took months of requests and badgering management to receive any resolution and compensation. The pipes bang for 10+ minutes when the heat turns on, so you will be woken up in the middle of the night by them. This is also on a busy corner, so if you are on a low floor, it will be loud. There is no control over the heat, and the heat radiates out, especially if you are near the boiler, which causes the rooms to be extremely warm when transitioning from fall to winter and winter to spring. Advice to landlord: control the pests”

“Unit 2A Pros: Great location, good super when things are broken Cons: Heater in winter made really loud noise, was on second floor so lower floors heard it”

“Pros: Great place to start in NYC Cons: Heating, Location, Laundry”

“Pros: Good big space Cons: Broken closet door”

“Pros: Clean, nice doormen Cons: Management office is terrible. Advice to landlord: More amenities would be good”

“Pros: The staff and management are great! Cons: Scaffolding around the building. Advice to landlord: No advice to owner.”

“Pros: Very nice porters and building staff Cons: Building has a pest control problem- had a mouse in our very high-floor apartment. Also, lobby smells like trash over the summer since the trash room is on the main level. Building in general is old and is kind of falling apart- regular water outages with super aerated pipes”

“Pros: Great doormen Gym Good location Cons: Very strict about moving in and out Street noise can be very loud. They need better windows. We had a mouse”

“Pros: Awesome doormen, good location Cons: Can’t think of any Advice to landlord: Consider rent reductions”