All 22 tenant reviews.

“Unit 10B Pros: Ceilings were high. Never saw a pest in my year there. It was nice not having to go all the way downstairs to throw out my trash. Eddie the super was nice and mostly helpful. Didn’t raise the rent much on renewal. Cons: Management (DSA) was pretty rude (not the super, the actual management). Entire 15 floor building serviced by 2 elevators — 1 is always out of order. Takes a couple minutes for the elevator to come. Definitely missed the train a few times because of that. Apartments are TINY, don’t have closets in any of the bedrooms. Living room didn’t have any windows. Don’t think we ever had a smoke detector in there, not sure if that’s legal… Washers and dryers constantly broken and swallowing your money. People don’t really smile or say hi in the elevators, pretty heads down.”

“Unit 10E Pros: I always felt very safe in the building, the super/maintenance staff and building management were always all very helpful and respond quickly to needs, high ceilings and big windows with bedrooms to fit a queen sized bed was great all for the price, upgraded bathroom and kitchens, building is relatively quiet as well and great location with easy access to so many subway lines, path or the ferry’s Cons: Not all bedrooms get the most light despite them having windows, an occasional water bug from drains to be very careful of keeping closed Advice to landlord: Monthly spray for cockroaches especially in summer months as was unreliable to get exterminator to come consistently”

“Pros: Good location. Responsive management. Cons: Package room access.”

“Pros: Great super, responsive management Cons: Elevators sometimes broken, heat broken”

“Unit 3B Pros: The super is extremely responsive and helpful, the building is never too loud and is well taken care of, and the neighbors always seemed nice. Great location, close to a ton of train lines! Cons: There are smaller rooms, elevator could be slow at times”

“Pros: big rooms and living space, responsive super and management Cons: location is not the best”

“Pros: no roach/bug/noise problems. Cons: Apartments are extremely cramped though, no A/C. Garbage management is weird, chute is closed and the super comes and cleans it up everyday outside. Water tweaked out once and filled the tub, wouldn't drain, disgusting water. Small rooms, gets easily dirty. Ok price.”

“Pros: Nice kitchen size, elevators are reliable, no major issues Cons: No windows in living room for C units. Older pipes lead to brown water when haven’t used water in a while. Advice to landlord: Na”

“Pros: Eddie the super is great! He really helps out when needed. Trash is put per floor which is super easy and convenient Water pressure is insane Cons: Elevator is so slow Sometimes had cockroaches Feels old”

“Pros: big rooms, high ceilings Cons: bugs in bathroom”

“Pros: Convenient, decent room size Cons: No frills, no closet space”

“Pros: Elevator, attentive super, no mice and very few bugs Cons: Heat can be overpowered, lose hot water in shower sometimes, infrequent bugs”

“Pros: Close to train lines Cons: Building is a bit old and no amenities”

“Pros: Super takes good care of building; cleans floors frequently and good garbage management. No pest issues at all for the year I have lived here. Cons: The C units do not have windows in the living room. Construction sometimes was annoying at night. Bedrooms tiny, full bed barely fits. Drainage in kitchen sink and shower is not great, have to use draino alot and must clean out twice a week or more.”

“Pros: Nice location. Super is responsive. Shared spaces are cleaned daily. Cons: Elevators and washing machines occasionally didn't work. Doors did not isolate noise at all, so can hear into other apartments from the outside and hear outside from inside. Extremely small space and poor lighting. Heater sometimes wasn't on when it was cold outside or it's very high even though it was warm outside. Drainage issues.”

“Unit 11A Pros: Rent is on the cheap side, location is convenient, super is responsive, lobby and floors are kept clean. Cons: Elevator is slow (but seems to have sped up after recent repairs), laundry machines can get packed, rooms/kitchens are on the small side. Advice to landlord: The heat doesn’t need to be so aggressive!”

“Unit 11E Pros: Good sized bedroom, heat works well Cons: Cockroaches, elevator goes out of service a lot, small bathroom, w/d in laundry room does not work well Advice to landlord: Needs modern renovation”

“Pros: - elevator - laundry in building - live in super - tall ceilings - convenient to subway Cons: - old -cockroaches sometimes - stolen packages - weird elevator Advice to landlord: - better package management”

“Pros: No serious issues with the apartment, response super for small repairs Cons: Sometimes a lot of noise and weird smells from consistent parties in the building, disorganized package room, significant rent raise in 2022 Advice to landlord: N/a”

“Pros: Edie, the super, is very on top of things. He’s a man of few words but is responsible and responsive when there’s a concern. If you respect the building and his hours, since he lives there, he will pull through and help when needed. We never had any pest issues. Cons: Maiden Lane can be a little gritty but you can’t beat the location. You’re a short walk to the west side highway and the seaport and Fulton station. It can be a little desolate in the middle of winter but other than that it’s a solid building.”

“Pros: Rent was on lower end when I moved in Cons: Rent raised aggressively later”

“Pros: Price, cleanliness, location Cons: Drafty, some bugs,”