Back to MAYFLOWER 221, LLC

All 11 tenant reviews.

MAYFLOWER 221, LLC · avg 2.5 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Mar 2026

Unit 4 Pros: Location, price, and rooftop access. Cons: Poor management. Lease agreement never sent timely, cockroaches, mice, trash being left in the lobby, bathroom ceiling fell in on itself.

223 EAST BROADWAY · Manhattan
★★★★Sep 2024

Unit 18 Pros: When I first moved into this building in 1956, it was clean with brass mailboxes so shiny you could see your face in them and beautiful murals in the hallway on the first floor. Cons: When the building was sold to Elizabeth Weiss, it became a slum dwelling with poor heating, dirty hallways and those polished mailboxes became rusty. Advice to landlord: I moved out in 1969. Building was sold, renovated & now permanently closed. Wonder why?

223 EAST BROADWAY · Manhattan
★★★★★Oct 2022

Pros: Perfect location, neighbors are all fine Cons: Cockroaches and we’ve had mice a couple of times.

223 EAST BROADWAY · Manhattan
★★★★★Sep 2022

Pros: Location and price Cons: Bed bugs Broken appliances (dishwasher and washing machine) Mice Leaky ceiling Uncontrollable heat (way way too hot) Advice to landlord: Don’t market these units as “comes with washer and dryer and dishwasher” and then not fix them when they break.

223 EAST BROADWAY · Manhattan
★★★★★Sep 2022

Pros: Location is not bad Cons: Could be more cleaner Advice to landlord: Hire someone to clean better

223 EAST BROADWAY · Manhattan
★★★★Sep 2022

Unit 4 Pros: - great location - rooftop access (technically not allowed but everyone went up anyway) - we had the apartment with the private deck - friendly neighbors - couldn't hear neighbors in our apartment - nice (but sometimes not too helpful) super - allowed for rent reduction during covid Cons: - management was slow to respond to any issues and when they did reply the work was pretty bad - we didn't have a working fridge for a month and only when we said we wouldn't pay rent did they replace it - garbage area was a bit of a shit show, oftentimes had rats - packages sometimes got stolen, and despite there being a "working" camera, management said they couldn't do anything about it; we believed it was strangers who got in vs. neighbors though Advice to landlord: - update rent payment system - would be helpful if management was more responsive

223 EAST BROADWAY · Manhattan
★★★★★Mar 2022

Unit 19 Pros: I guess the rent was decent and the location was good. Washer/Dryer in unit was nice. Cons: Management never responds to calls and rarely returns emails, stairwell had trash and hadn't been cleaned in years, trash was thrown under the stairs which is definitely not up to code, unit had bugs, bathtub was incredibly small, management never returned my security deposit Advice to landlord: Dorothy should learn how to use a phone and write a clear email

223 EAST BROADWAY · Manhattan
★★★★★Mar 2022

Pros: Location! subway grocery close by Cons: Roof leaking water Advice to landlord: Get your act together

223 EAST BROADWAY · Manhattan
★★★★★Feb 2022

Pros: Great location and big common areas Cons: Massive Pest problem not handled by management. roof caving in Advice to landlord: Be better

223 EAST BROADWAY · Manhattan
★★★★Oct 2021

Pros: Great location, quiet street, laundry in unit, dishwasher Cons: Small space for 4 people

223 EAST BROADWAY · Manhattan
★★★★★Apr 2021

Pros: The area is good Cons: The supposedly renovated apartments do not have noise insulation between floors and the gap causes the footsteps noise, music to be heard even louder, as a result of that and to the inconsiderate who cares little about their neighbors you will have moments of great disgust, the heater pipes make a lot of noise and the leaks are constant since the repairs are not supervised and apparently they are made with cheap labor will causes them to be frequent, the garbage is thrown on the floor and not in the trashcan, there is a super but he doesn’t live in the area. the cell phone antennas on the roof generate interference, and apparently there is an arrangement with spectrum (Time Warner) so you can’t use Verizon or optimun not Dish, not Direct TV, ….. nothing else only Spectrum. Advice to landlord: Fix those cons issues

223 EAST BROADWAY · Manhattan
Advertisement