All 5 tenant reviews.
HONEYWELL WASHINGTON LLC · avg 3.0 ★★★★★ · New York City
“Pros: Gym, location, locked package room, kind super, space size Cons: Questionable tenants who steal packages, hallway reeking of smoke, cockroaches, expensive/overpriced, echoing hallways that carry noise. The apartment looks nice, but everything cheaply constructed such as uneven flooring and sloppy paint job, door handles that keep falling off Advice to landlord: Make hallways nicer, stop smokers”
— 458 SAINT JOHNS PLACE · Brooklyn“Unit BD Pros: - In a renovated unit which has nice appliances, including good AC/heat system - Good amenities (laundry room, gym, elevator) - Great location and good size Cons: - Rent increases are too high - Can get loud, especially on the first floor - I've heard rats in the ceiling - Lots of issues to fix upon move-in but not too many after that - Management doesn't communicate when service people have to visit”
— 458 SAINT JOHNS PLACE · Brooklyn“Unit 5F Pros: Unit itself was recently renovated, but clearly rushed as paint was splotched, floors were uneven, appliances were just not actually installed properly, cabinets were falling, etc. Gym is okay. Roof view is pretty. Cons: Management was absolutely useless. They pretend they'll take care of an issue then a year goes by and they haven't given any updates despite over a dozen attempts at communication. They make promises and smile to your face but never actually follow through with anything. Super has so much attitude with doing anything and plays down any genuine problems you have. He also frequently claims he'll be there to help with something (in the same day) and then just never shows up, even with reminders. He's also just kind of mean. Some of the other neighbors in the building can be nice but so many are just incredibly inconsiderate. Many will just smoking openly in the hallways. The ventilation in this building SUCKS and that smoke will easily slip into the units and you'll be inhaling it from your living room. I've had to make several 311 complaints for this place. Bugs, water issues, secondhand smoke that management won't do anything about. Can't wait till my lease is over. Advice to landlord: Spend your resources making the building actually hospitable to tenants living there, not just making it look like a superficially pretty place for new ones. Actually communicate and follow through with standard of living improvements.”
— 458 SAINT JOHNS PLACE · Brooklyn“Pros: Renovated apartment - Heating and cooling is good - Finishing is good - New gym and office area is nice - FOB into building nice Cons: - Laundry room can be locked but is left propped open. Some random person wandered into the building and stole our laundry (caught on camera) but no changes were made. - Rats scampering in ceilings - No smoking policy not enforced sufficiently, common areas and ventilation stinks - No ventilation in the hallways, weird smells - Occasional cockroaches - Elevator out of service sometimes (around 6 times past half year) - People don't clean up after themselves at the gym - Super lies about when they're going to come over/come back if you don't follow up with them Advice to landlord: Act on tenant requests, especially smoking and ventilation violations”
— 458 SAINT JOHNS PLACE · Brooklyn“Pros: Recent addition of key fob entry, package room, and gym Cons: Multiple issues with leaks, AC, and hot water. Flooring is cheap fake wood that is coming up in many places in the unit. Pests in the walls Dryers often don't dry”
— 458 SAINT JOHNS PLACE · Brooklyn