Back to GOTHAM CAPITAL REALTY LLC

All 10 tenant reviews.

GOTHAM CAPITAL REALTY LLC · avg 3.6 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★May 2025

“Pros: Good value for amenities. Never had any issues with utilities, building management was friendly and responsive with getting appliances fixed. Nice rooftop space. Cons: Odd smell coming from air vents at times, never fixed. Neighbors lazy about leaving clothes in shared washing machines, leaving dog hair everywhere and they were frequently broken. Takes forever to get laundry done. Nearly had to sue to get deposit back but did eventually receive it in full. Leasing company extremely disorganized and lazy about this.”

— 68 WILLOUGHBY STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★May 2025

“Pros: Almost floor-length windows, laundry on every floor Cons: Apartment was a flex but was not advertised as such because the pictures were from when the unit was a 1 br. (We moved during covid, so we couldn’t view the apartment while it was still occupied.) Our electric bills were abnormally high (we’ve lived in NYC our entire lives), but management wouldn’t confirm if our apartment or the building was connected to the meters of the stores below us.”

— 68 WILLOUGHBY STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Feb 2024

“Unit 3B Pros: modern finishes super is active Cons: management slow to respond lots of construction ventilation not great”

— 68 WILLOUGHBY STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Mar 2023

“Unit 2C Pros: Great location and the rooftop is nice Cons: Management takes forever to respond, and when they do, it's only to ask something from you. Our dishwasher was broken for over a year, despite multiple attempts to fix, only to discover it never had a water line to begin with and they refused to install one (or lower our rent as a response). Our window shattered in the middle of February and it took weeks to fix. Avoid them at all costs!!!!!!! Advice to landlord: Respond to your tenants and actually be decent humans”

— 68 WILLOUGHBY STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Mar 2022

“Pros: Exposed brick walls, modern appliances, nice rooftop, laundry on each floor. Standalone AC/heating units are a nice touch. Great location near Jay St-Metrotech subway. Cons: It's on an extremely loud and busy street, and next door to a very loud community center that plays music til 3AM+ every few weeks. Management is not super responsive for repairs, Advice to landlord: Be more responsive.”

— 68 WILLOUGHBY STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Mar 2022

“Pros: Location is amazing. Light through windows is good. Management responsive, but not super fast at responding. Super is also eventually going to fix things. Although I've seen bugs outside and in the basement, I haven't seen them inside the apartment unit. Cons: Street noise is loud. Sometimes there are folks from street who gain access to the building. (Lack of) Package delivery has been a problem. Heat not included (except high bills year round for electricity). During heavy storms, there are leaks everywhere and basement floods. Roof smells like fried chicken during the summer due to chicken restaurants below units. Advice to landlord: Investigate the roof leaks!”

— 68 WILLOUGHBY STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Feb 2022

“Pros: Building kept clean. Shared laundry on each floor, repairs made quickly when needed. Cons: No package room/area. In unit repairs took several visits - seemed like cheap work. Balcony door repair was never completed after 6+ months of requests Advice to landlord: Streamline service requests”

— 68 WILLOUGHBY STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Nov 2021

“Pros: Dog friendly. Nice deep kitchen sink. Nice rooftop that smells like fried chicken. Good gym. Cons: Sometimes you can hear the train at night. The sliding laundry doors suck on all floors. The kitchen and bathroom do not have ventilation. The basement floods. Advice to landlord: Fix the laundry doors.”

— 68 WILLOUGHBY STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Jun 2021

“Pros: High ceilings, location Cons: Lease misrepresented amenities, constant break ins and stolen packages and owners do not care at all, air units horrible, lazy super, dirty floors, too expensive for all the issues.”

— 68 WILLOUGHBY STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Jan 2021

“Pros: Building amenities and residents are great. Cons: I don’t say this lightly... building Management might be the WORST I have ever experienced in my life. 0 responsiveness. 0 accountability & always lying about real issues This building had an problem with break-ins on a weekly basis. Tons of packages stolen because of a faulty front door locking system. The owners response? “It’s just part of living in the neighborhood.” The security cameras dont even have sight on the front door so if your package gets stolen, they can’t & wont help you. Advice to landlord: Dont be so negligent. Respond to tenants emails. Fix issues when requested and take accountability! For the love of gxd”

— 68 WILLOUGHBY STREET · Brooklyn
Advertisement