Back to GETHSEMANE GARDEN

All 8 tenant reviews.

GETHSEMANE GARDEN · avg 4.1 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Nov 2024

“Pros: Location, big apartments, good amenities, good staff Cons: Laundry machines and elevators frequently broken, smelly lobby due to proximity of grocery store Advice to landlord: Repair laundry machines”

— 338 EAST 8 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Feb 2024

“Pros: Nice staff, outdoor garden, gym and laundry room, Amazon hub, great location and spacious apartments, rent controlled Cons: Adjacent to a supermarket so there was usually a funky smell in the lobby from the prepared food counter. No roof access. Laundry machines, elevator, gym equipment would break regularly and not get addressed quickly. No full time doorman. Persistent mouse issues”

— 338 EAST 8 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★May 2022

“Pros: Clean apartment. No bugs. Rarely any water, etc issues. Very helpful Super. Cons: Occasional issues with heat/cooling”

— 338 EAST 8 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Oct 2021

“Pros: Super, neighbors, location Cons: My ac hasn’t whited for 8 months Advice to landlord: Fix the ac”

— 338 EAST 8 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Aug 2021

“Pros: Part time doormen, two elevators, shared patio, laundry in building, garbage chute on each floor. Bill the super, and the porter are nice, as are the two doormen. Cons: Management company is just okay, sometimes hinder porter/super from doing X or Y. Shared patio needs serious pest control help. Ptac a/c units are fickle and expensive on the electric. Advice to landlord: Please think about letting porter and super do more with less paperwork, as theyre great. Please replace/update the ptac units.”

— 338 EAST 8 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Aug 2021

“Pros: Amazon prime locker is handy. Building staff (super, door people, janitorial folks etc) are all exemplary, super friendly wonderful people. Cons: Lots of rats in the neighborhood and also mice in the building. Can be very noisy. elevators break down a lot. If you are considering moving into this building and relying on the laundry room, don't do it. We are currently sharing 2 barely-functioning washing machines between 70 units and the management company constantly ignore residents and lie to us. It's pretty disgusting considering the price they are charging for rents for new tenants. If you dont care about laundry facilities and are comfortable with organizing pick up/drop off laundry that you pay for on top of rent, then its fine. Advice to landlord: Your management company is grossly neglectful.”

— 338 EAST 8 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Aug 2021

“Pros: Elevator & gym are nice to have Cons: They never respond about anything and half of my appliances are broken”

— 338 EAST 8 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Oct 2020

“Pros: Location, courtyard, staff, gym Cons: None to speak of Advice to landlord: None none none”

— 338 EAST 8 STREET · Manhattan
Advertisement