Back to F- ASTORID REALTY LLC

All 12 tenant reviews.

F- ASTORID REALTY LLC · avg 3.2 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Mar 2026

“Pros: Great price, well maintained building. Cons: Can hear people walking upstairs. Super isn't that available or reliable.”

— 238 EAST 50 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Aug 2025

“Pros: Room sizes are good Cons: Paper thin walls and ceilings”

— 234 EAST 50 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Apr 2025

“Unit B1 Pros: cheap rent, ability to use exterminator every week without extra cost Cons: super is not very responsive and is often rude. lack of natural lighting and issues with heat (ie. being too hot or either too cold in the winter)”

— 234 EAST 50 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Dec 2024

“Pros: Nice/ respectful neighbors, hallways and entrance cleaned once a month, no pests Cons: Laundry units in the basement would randomly break, not dry clothes, etc.. Advice to landlord: Being a bit more prompt when it comes to repairs”

— 242 EAST 50 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Jul 2024

“Pros: Great space, outdoor space, laundry, elevator, maintenance Cons: A good amount of bugs Advice to landlord: Regular maintenance for bugs”

— 238 EAST 50 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Mar 2024

“Pros: Hot water is good and the location is good. Cons: There are a lot of bugs regardless of it the exterminator comes. The landlord and super will not respond unless you keep calling. Advice to landlord: Clean up the place”

— 242 EAST 50 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Jun 2023

“Pros: Apartment is on a great street in midtown, and the people who live in the building are very nice. Cons: Supper ignored you when something serious happens to the apt like water damage or broken shower. Advice to landlord: Have better communication with your renters”

— 234 EAST 50 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Dec 2022

“Unit 4D Pros: Superb location, elevator, nice apartment Cons: Unprofessional super, packages get stolen quite frequently Advice to landlord: Change entrance lock system and set up cameras”

— 242 EAST 50 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Dec 2021

“Pros: - quiet if you have an apartment in the back - lots of space - updated appliances in kitchen including dishwasher - hardwood floors - good storage - pretty good natural light - laundry in building Cons: - no control over heat (even with radiators closed, apartment is so hot in winter) - shower is temperamental (temperature extremes change while you’re in shower, pressure changes) - toilet is a dinosaur, always running, need to hold for 5 seconds to flush - no fan in bathroom so paint peels and mold forms on ceiling, even with window and door open - wine bar right next to apartment is always SO LOUD - wine bar always has some sort of construction going on, LOUD - have had roaches and tried to contact exterminator but was a whole complicated process - garbage area is always a wreck with mice and flies -when we moved in, things weren’t working or set up correct - doors don’t close very well (front door even with lock is loose, bedroom door locking issues) - paint over outlets - have shut off our water before with no heads up Advice to landlord: Make updates to the bathroom that will last, hire a new super who will be communicative and kind and easy to contact, fix water issues and heaters”

— 242 EAST 50 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Oct 2021

“Pros: Location. Proximity to subways, bars Cons: Responsiveness. Not up to date”

— 242 EAST 50 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Jan 2021

“Pros: The building was clean (I never saw a single bug), the location is incredible, there is an elevator, heat was perfect, shower + water pressure were great Cons: No fan in the bathroom, loud courtyard due to wine bar’s outdoor seating, the landlord is not responsive, and the property managers are impossible to get a hold of and it took months to get our deposit back after threatening with a lawyer Advice to landlord: Get a responsive landlord and communicate better with your tenants.”

— 242 EAST 50 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Nov 2020

“Pros: Building is decently maintained. My units gets lots of sun. Hot water and water pressure is good. Elevator and washer dryer are reliable. Super is decently reliable Cons: Windows facing into center of building have a restaurant courtyard to deal with. Is quite loud until 11pm when they close. The landlord is incredibly unresponsive. They will ignore several emails at a time. Advice to landlord: Hire better property managers who actually respond to their email”

— 242 EAST 50 STREET · Manhattan
Advertisement