All 9 tenant reviews.

“Pros: Great building, location, people, super was amazing and responsive. Cons: Mice and roaches unfortunately but it was basically midtown manhattan so what do you expect”

“Unit 3a Pros: kind super larry spacious great location Cons: hot in summer high electric bill radiator very loud at times in winter mail often stolen Advice to landlord: better mail facilities fix radiator”

“Pros: -Responsive and helpful super who went above and beyond -Clean building -Good and clean laundry facilities in basement -Trash shoot on every floor Cons: -Our apartment constantly had mice despite the super sending an exterminator many times and plugging holes with wire mesh multiple times. Apartment is above a Dunkin and a bodega/deli so might be par for the course”

“Pros: Great super, nice apartments, rent never increased by too much Cons: Package theft was common, had mosquitoes randomly in the winter, water leak problems, a lot of noise from stalled trucks”

“Pros: Despite its drawbacks, this apartment building does have a couple of silver linings. Its prime location provides residents with convenient access to various amenities and services. Additionally, the in-building superintendent stands out as a positive aspect, being both amiable and responsive to residents' needs, offering a helpful and supportive presence in the midst of other challenges. Cons: Washer and dryer consistently broken Elevator gets stuck Packages often stolen Leaking ceilings Flies everywhere in the summer Water and power often shut off without warning Incredibly thin walls (can hear your neighbors cough) Hand over fist rent hikes each year (10%+) Poor sustainability rating from the city Pests (both roaches and mice) often in apartments and building Little to no support from building management Advice to landlord: Either do better or stop raising the rent astronomicaly”

“Unit PHG Pros: Our terrace on the 6th floor (Penthouse) was simply outstanding. One of the best kept secrets in NYC. Cons: The neighborhood got pretty seedy. Without a doorman, people would go in when the door was left open and our packages were stolen multiple times. Advice to landlord: Make sure people lock the front door. Perhaps partner with the buiding next door to allow them to receive tenant packages.”

“Pros: Nice and responsive super, with standard fixtures etc - older building so natural wear and not the cleanest but overall comfortable! Cons: Cannot control heating, pests, stolen packages, next to public housing and since no doorman they get in the building easily. Advice to landlord: Hire a doorman/ package room”

“Pros: Attractive interior with good-sized apartments Cons: Frequently came home to people smoking crack and/or passed out blocking the entrance to the building. Trash and dead roaches scattered in the lobby/basement. Building removed the exterminator sign up sheet they are legally required to post. Experienced several leaks in different radiators throughout the apartment and was told to wait and see if they go away on their own. The boiler/pipe system was incredibly loud for the duration of the lease and woke us up 2-5am for three months straight. Management did nothing and the super screamed at me when I complained. Was told the pipes were so old they were sagging and popped whenever the hot water went on. Management did not plan to fix because it would be too expensive for them. Terrible upkeep overall Advice to landlord: Fix the boiler/pipes, hire a better super, and be responsive to tenant complaints.”

“Pros: Building has an elevator, has been newly renovated, is really well maintained, with a great super Cons: 25th street can be pretty noisy and is just near some public housing so there is often police and fire activity often in the evenings. Advice to landlord: Keep doing what you’re doing. Lease renewals were reasonable and the building is well maintained!”