Back to CUMBERLAND APARTMENTS

All 16 tenant reviews.

CUMBERLAND APARTMENTS · avg 3.3 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Sep 2025

Unit 607 Pros: Unparalleled Location w/ Elevator that mostly works Immensely kind, responsive super Big windows Cons: Let me just put it this way. My refrigerator broke and it took them 4 months to replace it...with a model that was too wide to sit flush against the wall, taking up a ton of space. That was in February, and now it's fall. When I call maintenance it goes to voicemail, which is pretty standard for the three years I've lived in this place. Other neighbors have had similar problems getting repairs done in a timely manner. Oh yeah, and the oft-discussed roaches. The best you can do is to set down some of those gel traps and use the exterminator services each month, regardless if you see a bug or not. You will almost DEFINITELY see bugs; it's just a question of whether it's a daily jumpscare or monthly/seasonally if you're lucky. Advice to landlord: Treat tenants like people and give Pedro a gd raise!!!

249 CUMBERLAND STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Sep 2025

Pros: great location great super Cons: flooring is so creaky and old roach infestation awful property management

249 CUMBERLAND STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Aug 2025

Unit 401 Pros: Zero. Its cheap i guess. Cons: This is the worst run building ive ever lived in in 40 years of life. Pests, unresponsive management group, shady billing practices, runaway YOY rental increases. Stay away. Advice to landlord: Sell the building.

249 CUMBERLAND STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★Jul 2025

Pros: - great location - Pedro is a very helpful super - building is kept in decent shape Cons: - frequent issues, including bugs and leaks - the management stole my security deposit without any explanation or response - my attempts to move to a 1BR within the building were ignored, so I left Advice to landlord: treat your tenants with dignity

249 CUMBERLAND STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Mar 2025

Pros: Responsive and very friendly super, friendly neighbors, great location, clean building Cons: Apartment was on the smaller side

249 CUMBERLAND STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★Dec 2024

Pros: Pedro, the building super is responsive, and friendly. Plus, he decorates for Christmas! Good water pressure. Cons: Multiple break-ins to package room but problem has been fixed for last ~year. A few roaches while living on the first floor. An exterminator comes once a month for free which many people utilize. Dark units!

249 CUMBERLAND STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★Sep 2024

Unit 212 Pros: Rent stabilized, responsive super, incredible location Cons: ROACHES, generally run down, weak plumbing, fire safety LACKING

249 CUMBERLAND STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Sep 2023

Pros: Amazing location. Charming building. Respectful neighbored. Nice super. Cons: Roach infestation that goes unmitigated. Monthly sprays were not enough.

249 CUMBERLAND STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★Jul 2023

Pros: the building is old Cons: the management office could be more responsive

249 CUMBERLAND STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★Jul 2023

Pros: Location, rent stabilized, and super Cons: Roaches, annoying Leadership, required 40 times after tax for rent which is ludicrous, expensive rent Advice to landlord: Should be cheaper

249 CUMBERLAND STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★Nov 2022

Unit 511 Pros: Great location, good super, quiet neighbors. Cons: Management is non responsive, 40 times rent after tax is insane Advice to landlord: Don't require 40 times rent after tax

249 CUMBERLAND STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Oct 2022

Pros: The location, restaurants nearby, pet friendly Cons: Management, super, lack of responsiveness, horrible roach problem Advice to landlord: Take care of the building.

249 CUMBERLAND STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Oct 2021

Pros: 1 block from fort Greene park. Cons: The building is cockroach infested, and the acoustics are horrible. Advice to landlord: Have the building fumigated.

249 CUMBERLAND STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Jul 2021

Pros: The super is amazing (if he’s still there). Great location. Spacious units. Laundry in building. Cons: Plumbing not great: toilet was really sensitive and always clogged. Kitchen sink overfilled with other peoples dishwater. Regular critters. Fire alarm went off a lot. Worst of all, I had the neighbor from hell. Absolute psychopath. Would pound on my wall for exercising or cooking at 6pm (yes, I chop onions too loud), then wound blare music so loud I could feel bass in my floor until 4am and started again at 9am. Threatened the woman above me. Cops were call over a dozen times. Was scared to be home; he was a big dude and I didn’t know what he was capable of. Owner did nothing despite constant complaints. I couldn’t get out of my lease even though it was unlivable at that point. Had to pay out the rest of my lease, but had to get out. He’s lived there for years so wouldn’t be surprised if he still is. Advice to landlord: Just do better. Jeeez.

249 CUMBERLAND STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★May 2021

Pros: Good location, very quiet, laundry in building Cons: Bad roach problem in my apartment and the hallways Advice to landlord: Control roach problems

249 CUMBERLAND STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★Jan 2021

Pros: Great location and lived in super. Cons: The bugs are very hard to get rid of. Can get noisy. Advice to landlord: Be more flexible in pandemic

249 CUMBERLAND STREET · Brooklyn
Advertisement