All 24 tenant reviews.
COOK PROPERTIES LLC · avg 3.8 ★★★★★ · New York City
“Pros: - Gym was high quality and well maintained - Convenient trash chutes - Rooftop was gorgeous and expansive - Great natural light Cons: - Not a great location, unhoused people often in vestibule or waiting outside to sneak in - Noise levels can be loud from neighbors - Package room is messy and not well maintained”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Unit 4D Pros: Elevator and massive roof top space were excellent. Maintenance ticket responses were fast. Cons: Lots of broken little things that never get fixed”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Pros: nice building, almost all young people Cons: immediate outside area is a bit hectic Advice to landlord: n/a”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Unit 8E Pros: Floor-to-ceiling windows on the corner of the building meant we literally saw the sunrise from our rooms and the sunset over Manhattan from our kitchen/living room. The bathroom was really nice, and the appliances were great. We also had several issues with the dishwasher, and they were able to come on multiple occasions and eventually fix it. Also, the central AC works very well. Cons: I have no clue how they calculated the electric bill, but it was INSANE. In the spring and fall, god forbid we didn't require the AC to be on, the bill would be $300. And it only went up from there... All the lights are LED, so idk how the bill was that high... but with these massive windows, it felt like we were in a greenhouse. It is crazy coming home in the WINTER to the apartment thermostat saying 85º, not to mention the summer. We needed the AC on at all times just to keep the cats safe, even when we weren't home. Also, when we moved in, they gave us the wrong keys, so we were in the building but locked out of our apartment until like 3am. Advice to landlord: Figure out why your electric bills are so high. Even without the AC being on, it was still around $300 per month.”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Pros: The building has a nice view and I liked that there is a laundry room, gym, and rooftop. Cons: The windows are poorly sealed and installed, leading to really high electricity bills in both winter and summer. The building also smells like marijuana frequently and management does not really address this problem. Management is not really responsive and the units are very small. Advice to landlord: Be more responsive”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Pros: BIG windows, clean and well maintained hallways and trash. Cons: Utilities are so expensive. Elextricity for a three bedroom is easily over 300 every month regardless of the season.”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Unit 12A Pros: Good amenities like laundry and gym. Management is responsive but doesn't always answer the question. Cons: Terrible soundproofing and window seals. The Con Ed bills are extremely high. The layouts are also kind of weird and the building doesn't have any actual closets. Overall the units are poorly built.”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Unit 12a Pros: New building, great amenities, easy garbage situation Cons: slow elevator, management is not very responsive over email, insane electricity bill, sus location, cheap build”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Pros: Clean laundry room and gym, everything functions well (heat, water, etc). Cons: Were charged $600 electric bill when we weren’t even in our unit and away traveling with all electricity consumers turned off. This is ridiculous.”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Unit 6D Pros: Pretty clean and modern, with rooftop access and a gym and laundry. the rooms had nice floor to ceiling windows and appliances were modern and clean Cons: Seems like the pipes were weak, as things would frequently get clogged. there was also some issues with package theft, and many times the front door would be left open.”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Pros: Stunning views and great sunlight! Management is responsive and handling things quick. Cons: Big windows so sun might sometimes be to strong Advice to landlord: ...”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Unit 7A Pros: Clean, no pests, newly built Cons: One elevator, no top roof access”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Pros: Building is nice Cons: Management is horrible Advice to landlord: Fix the elevator”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Pros: - Balcony is alright Cons: - despite what the listing might say, there is not a doorman. They claim they have a “digital doorman,” but clearly this person (if they exist) isn’t doing their job. package theft is rampant. They’re also generally bad with mail, we tested and only received 6/10 pieces of mail sent. - this isn’t managements fault per se (except for them displacing people), the neighborhood is not safe or pleasant. Sometimes people would be sleeping inside the building or going to the bathroom in the lobby. We also regularly saw people injecting drugs on the block. - management extremely negligent. The building is liability incarnated. Management is clearly not versed in their legal obligations. For example, the elevator broke and management took over ten days to arrange repair (there is only one elevator for 45 units too, so no backup). The elevator continued to break and management did not notify us when it did, meaning multiple people got stuck in the elevator for multiple hours. When a concerned resident emailed management about this, it took them SIX MONTHS to respond (I kid you not). - management routinely enters units without warning and in non-emergencies. They let the real estate agent in 5+ times without our permission (and on two occasions when we had told them not to enter) and allowed the new tenants to move in three days before our lease ended without notifying us or seeking permission. - as other people have said, management also predatory with security deposits. They tried to charge us $500 for two places on the wall where paint had been ripped off and then painted over the damage without telling us about the damage or about the paint job. They were clearly trying to pass the cost of a cosmetic repair (that owners are responsible to pay for) onto the tenants. When we told them they had to provide itemized receipts and that they hadn’t advised us of our rights (eg management must give tenants an itemized receipt of any damage and give them the opportunity to repair damages before deducting money from a deposit. - management fails constantly to notify of other repairs that might impact your life/health. Eg they won’t tell you when they’re repainting other units near you, the fumes can be terrible. - several times the doors to outside wouldn’t open from the inside. You literally would be unable to escape if there was an emergency, this place is a fire hazard and it’s only a matter of time before their negligence and inaction hurts somebody seriously. - If I typed out all the issues with this building/management my thumbs would fall off. Don’t move here. Advice to landlord: Be better”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Pros: Nice views, modern apartment, near the JMZ line and not far from the L or G Cons: Area is okay, elevator breaks down every few weeks and management won’t compensate for that, it takes several months and many messages for management to fix something like the door for the package room (where our packages were getting stolen).”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Unit 10e Pros: natural light. Small gym. roof deck. close to train. working appliances, dish washer. Cons: Pretty bad area. Lots of issues with the elevator, which caused huge problems. Some package theft. Not much space in the actual apartment. Advice to landlord: Please fix your elevator. down for 10 days is unacceptable.”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Pros: Views of the Manhattan skyline are the only positive really, and relative proximity to J, M train line. Although J skips our stop in the morning so it really only serves as the M line if commuting to Manhattan for work in the morning. Cons: Reflecting what others have said - negligent management, "nice" building that is actually cheaply built (thin walls, unsealed windows leading to high AC costs, leaks, key fob system that breaks all the time, elevator that breaks all the time). State of the building is always dirty, sticky floors. For example, elevator broke for a week and management ignored tenant pleas, including a request of a measly 25% reduction in rent, and ignored elderly or otherwise immobile people. I'll remind you this is a 12 story building with only 1 elevator. Also big issue with package theft. People have had issues getting security deposits back... Advice to landlord: Take care of your tenants. Don't be greedy and hire an in-person doorperson, more regular cleaning, and service maintenance requests promptly.”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Pros: Incredibly close to the M and the J, very clean building, close to a ton of stores and restaurants. Modern appliances and very beautiful apartment setup. Cons: Windows are huge which can be a pro but the constant light makes the apartment incredibly hot so it’s expensive to cool it down in terms of utilities. Vents were dusty and hard to clean. The AC smelled really bad sometimes. Advice to landlord: Check the HVAC.”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Pros: The view of the NYC skyline was the only nice thing about this place. Great light for my plants Cons: Landlords never returned our security deposit They had loud construction at random times of the day They never had porters clean the lobby or hallways which got super sticky and gross sometimes Our neighbors always threw parties and Managment didn’t do anything even after Multiple complaints Packages got stolen And our electricity bill was literally hundreds of dollars more than it should be considering how little AC and heat we used - I think one month it was like 800 dollars for just 2 people Advice to landlord: Be a better, decent human being and actually respond to your tenants instead of ignoring us”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Pros: Luxury Gym Shared rooftop View of the city Cons: Painfully high energy bills in the summer (had come Ed check my meter it was so high and unfortunately correct according to them.) Packages stolen Loud neighborhood Advice to landlord: Young tenants and the neighborhood isn’t the cleanest”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Pros: The building is “nice” elevator, washer/dryer, central air Cons: Management is rude. We reached out several times for assistance and were ignored. Constantly lied to by management in regards to repairs. Large parties during covid continued to happen and management did nothing about it. Tenants would remove my laundry from the washer IMMEDIATELY after completing. Not giving me even 5 mins to walk down and switch my load. Hallway is always sticky Advice to landlord: Selling 99% of your property. Landlords should not exist”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Pros: Easy commute to train, nice rooftop Cons: Sketchy neighborhood, packages stolen, no live in super, thin walls, told us they were building closets in room when the building first opened instead put ugly ikea wardrobe things in”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Pros: The place is so clean! The rooftop is nice and management solves ticket typically with the same day. Cons: They are strict about the pets in this building even though it’s suppose to be a ‘pet friendly’ place. Advice to landlord: Regulate parties on the roof more.”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn“Pros: Clean, responsive super Cons: Unsealed window. High electricity cost”
— 46 COOK STREET · Brooklyn