All 12 tenant reviews.
CONEY ISLAND AVENUE ORGANIZATION LLC · avg 3.0 ★★★★★ · New York City
“Pros: The neighborhood is amazing. Parking is easy for NYC. Cons: Major issues with heat, hot water, appliances, mold. The say the super lives in the building, he does not. He rarely responds to calls or texts. I have never seen him in the building The janitor is around everyday and is rude and aggressive to tenants. The owner doesn’t like to be bothered. They do not disclose the name, email or phone number of any management company. This property owner will do the bare minimum. Advice to landlord: Take your tenant’s complaints seriously.”
— 527 CONEY ISLAND AVENUE · Brooklyn“Pros: Our apartment had walls and running water Cons: We moved in during the fall and had no heat or hot water for days, due to management not setting up the heater correctly. Our apartment had several finishing issues that we unfortunately only noticed after we were moved in. The outside of our apartment window was filthy and management refused to clean it. During the summer, we could NOT sleep with our windows open, as 18 wheelers & vehicles on Coney Island Ave. would wake us up at night. Dealing with management was useless, they are responsive and kind during the lease setup process, but go mostly MIA afterwards Advice to landlord: Learn to be kind”
— 527 CONEY ISLAND AVENUE · Brooklyn“Pros: Good location, good space, rooms are nice, facilities are modern and clean Cons: The building is new but somehow falling apart - none of the floors are level, floorboards coming off, the tiles on the bathroom walls were coming off, there's constant leakage from the ceiling. Management is entirely unresponsive, they will ignore you unless you pester the janitor enough for a cell phone number that is different from the ones provided to tenants, that is the only way to get any help. And when you do talk to them, they are rude and dismissive.”
— 527 CONEY ISLAND AVENUE · Brooklyn“Pros: Very clean, well maintained. Cons: Some mold issues and cheap cabinets. Shotty job on construction”
— 527 CONEY ISLAND AVENUE · Brooklyn“Unit 4K Pros: I moved out 2 years ago. Had a nice super. In a super nice area. Cons: Had no clue who landlord was. Mailed a check to queens. Things were shoddily made. Things broke often.”
— 527 CONEY ISLAND AVENUE · Brooklyn“Pros: Pretty good overall Cons: Problem with roaches, sometimes unresponsive owners”
— 527 CONEY ISLAND AVENUE · Brooklyn“Pros: Close to the Prospect Park. Cons: We had a leaking ceiling for two years. It was taking months of complaints to get at least something done and the source of the leak was never fixed. We couldn't invite any guests because we have a huge hole in our living room.”
— 527 CONEY ISLAND AVENUE · Brooklyn“Pros: Lobby was well decorated. Cons: The management team flat out lied about amenities. Never saw them work on the rooftop deck even though they said it would be done before moving in. Gym was its own entity and had to pay for a membership. Heater did not work well and would have to use oven to heat apartment during the winter. They never fixed the problem and they only supplied us with one space heater for the living room. Water temperature would also take forever to get hot. They refused to give me my security deposit back after they broke into my apartment before my move out date and took pictures of it before it was cleaned. They also proceeded to throw out several of my furniture pieces during this time because they thought “I had already moved out”. They refused to pay for the furniture they got rid of (several thousand dollars worth). This is not only a terrible apartment but the management are frauds.”
— 527 CONEY ISLAND AVENUE · Brooklyn“Pros: The fast that each bathroom had a bathtub and not stand up shower Cons: Cockroaches everywhere, porter was overworked and always frustrated. No obvious building contact. Packages would be stolen. Rude owners and super Advice to landlord: Try and communicate more effectively and take care of problems as they arise.”
— 527 CONEY ISLAND AVENUE · Brooklyn“Pros: Janitor is responsive and does a good job, had a repair issue and once it got through management was handled promptly, good stove, fridge, and ac units Cons: Manager isn’t as responsive, dishwasher is terrible, internet choice is optimum, street noise is loud and trucks can shake the building, apartment seems like it was built quickly since measurements aren’t done well (e.g. can’t open the stove all the way since the dishwasher blocks it), laundry units don’t work well because they were installed wrong Advice to landlord: Fix the laundry room dryers (one blows into the other), other stuff seems difficult to fix since you just remodeled, the janitor is great”
— 527 CONEY ISLAND AVENUE · Brooklyn“Pros: Good location, close to a decent number of restaurants and grocery stores. Not a lot of street noise. The virtual doorman was a plus. Cons: Poor response rate from super and management. The porter handles everything and would often send angry responses in his own language via text. The apartment was FULL of roaches with no obvious cause or remedy. The walls were paper thin and I could hear my neighbors all through the night. I’ve had packages stolen from the lobby. The laundry machines would often not wash or dry my clothes properly. The central heat didn’t work for the first 2 months of winter and they distributed electric heaters. The oven and microwave weren’t cleaned properly before we moved in. Advice to landlord: Hire more help for the porter or make your super accountable. If you have phone numbers to reach out for help, make sure they actually work.”
— 527 CONEY ISLAND AVENUE · Brooklyn“Pros: I like the location. It’s close to the park and close enough to the train. The roof deck is nice in the summer. Sunit - the janitor -is kind and quick to respond. Cons: Where to begin? It started with a cockroach infestation that was horribly mismanaged and is still not under control, five months later. If you’re ever able to get in touch with management, they lie, gaslight, and harass any tenant who makes valid complaints and requests. The finishings appear nice at first, but everything is so poorly constructed that it ends up looking cheap very quickly. The super is rude, regularly skips appointments, and his “repairs” are rarely effective. Often time, the cheap repairs end up causing additional, more significant damage. Our heat hasn’t worked for weeks (it’s January) and management has ignored our requests for repairs. Our floor is so warped due to multiple dishwasher leaks (management was immediately notified each time and they neglected to make repairs for over a month) that our front door can barely open. On top of it all, neighbors often have their dogs (and cats) off leash in public areas. One of our neighbor’s dogs has peed on our door multiple times, leaving me to clean it up. The apartments might photograph nicely but do not be fooled. This place is overpriced and uninhabitable. Management are essentially slumlords. Avoid these apartments at all costs! Advice to landlord: Fire the super. Give the janitor a raise. Replace management. Handle repairs and pest problems properly from the beginning instead of looking for the cheapest option.”
— 527 CONEY ISLAND AVENUE · Brooklyn