Back to CATON PROPERTIES LLC

All 7 tenant reviews.

CATON PROPERTIES LLC · avg 2.4 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Aug 2025

“Pros: Close to subway station and Prospect Park. Lots of space. Cons: Roaches. Old fixtures and poorly maintained building.”

— 2023 CATON AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Jul 2024

“Pros: Beautiful apartment, nice neighbors Cons: Management left us with severe maintenance issues for months at a time, and were unresponsive and incompetent when communicating or solving issues.”

— 2023 CATON AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Dec 2023

“Unit 1 Pros: Large, apartments with character, good storage space Cons: Roach infestation is disgustingly out on control for over a year. They are incessant, management slaps non existent band aids over the issue.”

— 2023 CATON AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Sep 2022

“Pros: Very large apartments with tons of light and storage space. Great location, near Prospect Park, subway stations and lots of grocery stores, bars and resturaunts Cons: Not very clean, management is unresponsive, could use some renovations, packages get stolen a lot”

— 2023 CATON AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Jul 2022

“Pros: - Spacious apartment - Lots of storage - Big kitchen - Monthly pest control - Laundry room - 4 min walk to the B/Q line - Close to restaurants/stores on Flatbush Ave - Close to Prospect Park Cons: - Roaches - Inconsistent shower water temperature; the water will switch up temperatures mid shower, hard to get it where you want it - Toilet can overflow - No hot water sometimes, have to call Super - Weak electricity during the summer, power will go out if just two A/C’s are running at the same time. Turn on the TV? Even worse. - Stolen packages are common - Old floor boards, wood is split in some areas and sealed with only tape Advice to landlord: Invest in updating the building and apartments”

— 2023 CATON AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Jun 2021

“Pros: Pretty quiet, nice space Cons: Big roaches small roaches everywhere! Advice to landlord: Get rid of these roaches please!”

— 2023 CATON AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Jan 2021

“Pros: Decent price, near the subway, semi-renovated, on-site super, included heat/hot water, laundry on site Cons: Crumbling stairs, near-illegal low heat in winter, inconsistent water heat/pressure, shoddy work on "renovations", at least one burst pipe disaster Advice to landlord: Doing things cheap means they break more often, do it better and clean up a bit”

— 2023 CATON AVENUE · Brooklyn
Advertisement