Back to CARTHAGE 124TH L.P.

All 4 tenant reviews.

CARTHAGE 124TH L.P. · avg 3.3 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Mar 2025

“Pros: Great building. Nice location, close to subways, restuarnts, and shops. Really not noisy at all. Great view of the city skyline. Heat and AC work very well. Water pressure too high even. Very good gym. friendly doorman and super. Fast response to ticket. Cons: Management is new or not that competent. Always putting in new rules or changing rules. One or both elevator fails frequently. It is a bit overpriced for this area. Leased in Dec 2023 for 18 month lease, 2 free month, for 5650. Renewal offer starting June 2025 is 5850, no free month. Big rent jump.”

— 224 WEST 124 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Jul 2024

“Pros: Front desk / Concierge team are extremely friendly and very helpful The views are great and the shared common areas are kept very clean. Quick responses by management For the most part, very quite Cons: In-unit washer and dryers are a bit smaller and older than I'd like. Elevators can be out a lot but it usually comes back up the next day”

— 224 WEST 124 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Apr 2024

“Pros: The views are amazing, from the balcony and the rooftop Cons: The manager is extremely disorganized and unprofessional. *Some* of the tenants are known to be racist (ironic considering the neighborhood they chose to live in)”

— 224 WEST 124 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Aug 2023

“Pros: My lease is almost over Cons: The Mgmt only cares about collecting rent, the attention to detail (cleanliness, timeliness in completing the building and etc) is a joke. We had an open trash area in the parking lot for months claiming it was the city’s fault. Advice to landlord: Deliver a better experience for your tenants”

— 224 WEST 124 STREET · Manhattan
Advertisement