Back to BENCHMARK 250 LLC

All 10 tenant reviews.

BENCHMARK 250 LLC · avg 3.4 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Mar 2025

“Pros: Nice staff and lobby, great location, convenient to subway; some beautiful apartments with nice floors, high ceilings, lots of closet space, beautiful natural light, easy temp control, good appliances, plumbing always worked, easy fixes were fixed quickly, no neighbor noise ! Cons: Street noise was loud, even high up; persistent leaks following rainstorms- management tried to fix repeatedly but gave up; pests (roaches; never mice) come through cracks in the walls and ceilings from water damage.”

— 2333 BROADWAY · Manhattan
★★★★★Oct 2024

“Pros: Doorman, 2 elevators, no severe pest issues. Cons: Super expects to be paid for regular unit maintenance or repair ( tipped above norm and expected, if he knows u dont tip EVERY TIME he will find excuses why the work can't be done ) Advice to landlord: Get a super who knows how to do the work Instead of making the the assistant super do everything”

— 2333 BROADWAY · Manhattan
★★★★★Oct 2023

“Pros: Location, doormen, laundry room Cons: Water pressure, no cold water, frequent heat loss, long term management Advice to landlord: Care about your tenants”

— 2333 BROADWAY · Manhattan
★★★★★Aug 2023

“Unit no Pros: The building is very friendly and safe with great staff and super. Cons: The rent increases led to myself and several neighbors needing to move out Advice to landlord: well maintained building”

— 2333 BROADWAY · Manhattan
★★★★★May 2023

“Pros: Location is a block from the subway. high ceilings Cons: Overpriced. NOT luxury in spite of price. Management is very stingy with the heat - everyone in the building has to use space heaters in spite of the radiators. There are german cockroaches in the walls so you have to keep all food in the fridge. Hallways are mopped by the staff, but there is a layer of grime because the hallways have never been properly power washed. No doorman late night, Owner refuses to put dogs and pets written on the lease, but the leasing agent tells you they allow them in the building. They do this so can consider you in breach of lease anytime they want. The building has very high turn over so to no fee but very high lease increases. Make sure you can afford at least 20% more your second year. Horrid building owner. Stay away! Advice to landlord: If you’re not going to treat tenants like kuxury tenants, stop trying to charge luxury prices.”

— 2333 BROADWAY · Manhattan
★★★★★Feb 2023

“Unit 8B Pros: Great apartment, views and buidling staff but get ready for your rent to go through the roof come renewal time. Cons: Rent increased by $600 when it was time renew and I didn’t have a COVID special. Super takes a while to actually fix your problem but when he does he’s good. Works best when incentivized. Advice to landlord: Don’t screw over your tenants with crazy rent hikes.”

— 2333 BROADWAY · Manhattan
★★★★★Jan 2023

“Pros: Wonderful staff, great neighborhood, decent units but often not up to standard that they charge. Tenants are excellent. Dog friendly. Cons: A lot of construction noise/light which will continue for some time. Repairs are hit or miss. Fairly frequent reports of rodents and pests. Management company has been increasing the prices of apartments (after covid specials gone) by extreme levels that are out of line with neighborhood and the general quality of the units available to rent. Elevators are not terrible but not always reliable.”

— 2333 BROADWAY · Manhattan
★★★★★Mar 2022

“Pros: - nice staff - super dog friendly - renovated units - neighbors are friendly - steps away from Riverside Park and dog runs - conveniently located to bars, restaurants, grocery stores - feel safe walking your dog at night Cons: - back facing units can be really dark/no light -avenue facing units can get a lot of noise pollution because of the construction across the street Advice to landlord: no advice to give, we enjoyed our stay here.”

— 2333 BROADWAY · Manhattan
★★★★★Jan 2022

“Pros: Beautiful lobby, friendly staff, nice neighbors. Everyone who lives here has a beautiful dog, almost like it's a prerequisite lol Cons: Takes forever to get anything done. No garbage shoots so everything piles up, but they take it out pretty quickly.”

— 2333 BROADWAY · Manhattan
★★★★★Mar 2021

“Pros: None that I can think of Cons: This building is under the worst management! And the superintendent that only looks for tips, if you don’t tip-off next time he will ignore you. Advice to landlord: They are the same like Super, once I confronted him that I will report him to his supervisor Kevin, he told me Go ahead.”

— 2333 BROADWAY · Manhattan
Advertisement