Back to ATLANTIC GARDENS LLC

All 4 tenant reviews.

ATLANTIC GARDENS LLC · avg 3.8 ★★★★ · New York City

★★★★Apr 2026

Pros: Charming, spacious, lots of natural light, shared backyard Cons: Occasional roaches in the summer, thin windows (poorly insulated), atlantic ave is loud Advice to landlord: Replace the windows and continue with the exterminator

531 ATLANTIC AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★Oct 2025

Unit A Pros: Location was pretty unbeatable. Cons: landlord was not responsive (super was responsive for things like repairs, but lease renewal was a really annoying process because of landlord unresponsiveness). Atlantic Ave can be noisy at times.

539 ATLANTIC AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★Aug 2024

Unit C Pros: The building is generally well-maintained. The super is overworked, but very responsive and kind. The management company has changed every year I have been here, and they all suck to some extent, but I don't have to interact with them much. Cons: The heat situation is horrible. My unit has better windows and insulation, so I have to keep my windows open all the time in the winter to keep my apartment below 80F. This is tough considering the amount of noise coming from Atlantic Ave. There has also been an increasing pest issue, which will likely only get worse given the food business moving into the ground-floor commercial units.

535 ATLANTIC AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Sep 2022

Pros: Clean Low rise construction with some nice historic details Friendly super on premises during weekdays Shared mews-style courtyard with other tenants from other buildings and commercial spaces Cons: Loud neighbor downstairs at the coworking/event space holds noisy parties Landlord raises rent significantly, units used to be rent stabilized Noisy construction at nearby Alloy Block Nice craft beer bar downstairs closed down due to rent increase (same landlord) Messy garbage collection leads to rat infestation at shared backyard Small living spaces without sufficient closet space Loud and ineffective kitchen exhaust Advice to landlord: Value good tenants and keep them by maintaining their rent. Don’t push them out and leave behind vacant spaces, especially along your commercial frontage, since activity at night along the street makes the neighborhood safer.

535 ATLANTIC AVENUE · Brooklyn
Advertisement