Back to AMSTERDAM AVENUE INVESTOR, LLC

All 8 tenant reviews.

AMSTERDAM AVENUE INVESTOR, LLC · avg 3.1 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Jun 2025

Pros: Location is great, steps away from Columbia Cons: We had a rat issue and the apartment was dark

1272 AMSTERDAM AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★★Sep 2024

Pros: Lots of space for a reasonable price, open floor plan means kitchen with lots of room, in unit laundry Cons: If something goes wrong, it will not be fixed unless they deem it an emergency. Our washer and dryer were broken for months before we finally gave up and fixed it ourselves. Watch out for mold and water damage

1268 AMSTERDAM AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★★Oct 2022

Pros: Great location, near Columbia. The overall management is very responsive. The apartment had a really cute set up, as well. Cons: (See the title of this review). The building not kept up very well / the building could use a lot of TLC. There are mice & massive roaches (it was clear from the start of my lease that there was an infestation). The building super was pretty absent (not 24/7 super but you have to call the central management line) Washer, no dryer.... the garbage disposal is around the corner, not in the building. Advice to landlord: I think the management is generally responsive & there's some good things going for the building (location, setup, etc.), but they also need to invest in their buildings a lot more.

1270 AMSTERDAM AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★★Jun 2022

Unit 4C Pros: Our maintenance guy is the only person who does anything. He is so kind and helpful. He is great at fixing things. There is laundry in unit and generally, it's pretty quiet. Never had any stolen packages. Cons: Takes forever to get anything fixed and almost never fixed properly if not done directly by our maintenance guy. As soon as management needs to be involved nothing gets done. Charges exorbitant rent for a pretty crummy building. Did not turn on my heat until WAY past deadline. Did not turn OFF heat until way into warm months. Advice to landlord: Improve your building if you want to hike the rent. Fix the problems PROPERLY. Actually manage the buildings you own.

1272 AMSTERDAM AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★★May 2022

Unit 3D Pros: Updated kitchen with dishwasher Nice hardwood floors Pretty good natural Combo washer/dryer in unit (does breakdown easily) Cons: Unresponsive management Plumbing problems

1270 AMSTERDAM AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★★Apr 2022

Pros: Quiet part of town. Good rent amount. Cons: No elevator makes it hard to move in and out. Some units are weirdly shaped.

1268 AMSTERDAM AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★Nov 2021

Pros: Nice and quiet building. Laundry in the unit. Cons: Garbage was around the corner from the building. Big hassle. Towards the end of the stay, I found a mouse in my apartment. Calls to the super went unanswered. Advice to landlord: Better garbage management, pest control.

1270 AMSTERDAM AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★Feb 2021

Pros: The room is quite nice, small but clean. Great water pressure! Sup is very helpful and friendly. The surrounding is good, quite friendly and lot's of food. Washer-dryer in the room is also a big plus Cons: If your apartment is facing Amsterdam Ave(not sure about the other side), It's quite noisy during the evening, with tons of trucks passing every night, also very close to the bus stop. The heat is not very good, the window can't keep the warmth. Advice to landlord: Improve the heat

1272 AMSTERDAM AVENUE · Manhattan
Advertisement