★★★★★Apr 2025
“Pros: Great location. Nice quiet building. Cons: Often dirty, especially with construction. Gutting apartments means construction noise ALL OF THE TIME. Money hungry landlord is renovating more and more units. Terrible management - nothing ever gets fixed. Advice to landlord: Care about the people. Not just the money.”
— 54 CARMINE STREET · Manhattan★★★★★May 2024
“Pros: Great windows, ceiling height, light. Cons: Super is unresponsive even in emergencies.”
— 54 CARMINE STREET · Manhattan★★★★★Jul 2022
“Pros: Affordable, great West village block Cons: Packages not always secure. Currently behind scaffolding.”
— 54 CARMINE STREET · Manhattan★★★★★Oct 2021
“Pros: Great location and quiet building Cons: Mice always in/around building. Restaurant below does not deposit trash well Advice to landlord: Be more responsive and proactive”
— 54 CARMINE STREET · Manhattan