Back to 916-918 THIRD AVENUE

All 4 tenant reviews.

916-918 THIRD AVENUE · avg 2.8 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Oct 2025

“Unit 2C Pros: The location is very ideal Cons: The building is infested with roaches! Especially the second and third floors! No proper pest control is taken place even though an exterminator does come once in a while, it does not help! Yes this is New York City but there is a difference between seeing a few bugs and an infestation!!!! This place is too expensive to have these types of issues!! Also side note, the walls are thin so if you have a noisy neighbor, you can hear every conversation. Advice to landlord: FUMIGATION AND PROPER OUTSOURCING FOR PEST CONTROL”

— 916 3 AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★★Nov 2023

“Pros: The super was very helpful and responsive. The apartment complex itself was also very centrally located and easily accessible from anywhere in the city. Cons: The apartment from the day we moved in was dirty. Floors were disgusting, I was scared to look under the claw foot tub in the bathroom and the bathroom itself looked like borderline a crime scene. We also never found droppings/saw a mouse but would notice things like chewed garbage bags etc. so there was definitely a problem with mice which we could see when we'd go to take the garbage out downstairs. That said - the apartment is really and reasonably priced for new york, so if you are looking for a decent place to live it wouldn't be terrible.”

— 916 3 AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★★Jan 2022

“Pros: great location, you can find furnished apt, amazing super and very friendly landlord Cons: very old, it will need some renovations Advice to landlord: renovate the building entrance and some of the building bathrooms.”

— 916 3 AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★★Sep 2020

“Pros: location location location Cons: Rats old dusty no ventilation Black mold cheap fittings stench cramped expensive Advice to landlord: reduce your price”

— 916 3 AVENUE · Manhattan
Advertisement