Back to 660-DEGRAW ST. LLC

All 4 tenant reviews.

660-DEGRAW ST. LLC · avg 1.8 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Jun 2024

“Pros: Good location. The price might seem good. Cons: Honestly, the whole thing was a farce. The owner, Joe Catalano, failed to adequately fix the heating for two years. Another apartment in the building went without heating for three years: Joe Catalano said he would cover the cost of buying electric heaters, which he did not. A previous tenant had to take Joe Catalano to court to get their deposit back. When we had a mouse infestation Joe Catalano brought round glue traps, but would not remove the traps once they had captured mice. Outside overflowing trash meant that rats were a constant presence. Advice to landlord: Hire someone who knows how to manage the building without giving themselves an electric shock when they attempt to repair things.”

— 173 4 AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Mar 2022

“Pros: floor throug small building Cons: nice and 4tha ave traffic. portly maintained common area Advice to landlord: please resolve mice issue”

— 173 4 AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Nov 2021

“Pros: Fairly affordable rent and good location and neighborhood Cons: The landlord Joe is terrible at being proactive at fixing things and addressing problems when they arise. Usually takes week , months even years to fix any problems Advice to landlord: Get a proper management company to handle your rents. And stop doing everything yourself”

— 173 4 AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Oct 2021

“Pros: Pets are allowed. Cons: Irresponsible, rude, robber. This is what you are signing up for if you rent from the slumlord Joe Catalano. Radiator broke down in the middle of the winter. No response for three days. Took him more than two weeks to get it fixed. Rude to the tenant, spans himself on your furniture without ask. Worst, he will NOT return your security deposit “until someone else moves in”. And he will threat you when you demand your money back according to the law. AVOID HIM! Advice to landlord: See you in court.”

— 173 4 AVENUE · Brooklyn
Advertisement