All 4 tenant reviews.
56 MORTON STREET REALTY, LLC · avg 3.0 ★★★★★ · New York City
“Unit 3W Pros: The street itself is beautiful - the super is a really nice guy who takes care of the trash well Cons: - worst building management ever - rats inside the building and management doesn’t care - decaying and disgusting hallways and dangerous stairs that are falling apart - fire occurred in june 2024 and the building didn’t start construction until january 2025 leaving everyone in unsafe conditions - multiple break ins and stolen packages and building didn’t add in any additional security measures - building always smells - you can hear everything in every apartment - no heat in winter to the point I was wearing gloves and winter jacket inside, nothing happened until threatening to call 311 - old windows with terrible draft in winter Advice to landlord: Do Better!!!”
— 56 MORTON STREET · Manhattan“Unit 3 Pros: Cheap rent for the area Location is good Quiet neighbors and street Cons: - Rats inside the building in the walls: building management was contacted regarding this and they completely ignored all emails and calls. - Fire damage throughout the building that has not been repaired in months (fire was in June 2024) - Stairs are dangerous and have not been repaired in what I would assume is 50 years+ - The building is not secure, there have been break ins - overall the management company/owner have been impossible to deal with, and they have allowed people to live in/rent unlivable conditions while collecting full rent Advice to landlord: Sell the building”
— 56 MORTON STREET · Manhattan“Pros: beautiful street and perfect location. very quiet. great amount of space for the price Cons: building management sucks ass and building was so old it felt a little unsafe / suspicious”
— 56 MORTON STREET · Manhattan“Pros: Beautiful street Owner very responsive (but has since hired a manager who didn't return our deposit for >2 months so your mileage may vary) Charming apartment Nice neighbors Relative few pest issues Great value Cons: It was always super hot. In winter the heat was super high all the time, we had to sleep with the AC on. In the summer we had to sleep with the AC on Advice to landlord: Turn down the heat in the winter. It'll save you a lot of money and make the building more comfortable It's starting to get a bit run down. Some cosmetic fixes (refinish floors?) would make a world of difference”
— 56 MORTON STREET · Manhattan