Back to 5505-1500 CARROLL STREET BROOKLYN LLC

All 3 tenant reviews.

5505-1500 CARROLL STREET BROOKLYN LLC · avg 3.7 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Jul 2025

“Unit 4B Pros: Solid building with a few rent stabilized units. The layouts help the apartments feel spacious and the sunlight access is really good. Newly finished interiors in many units have really nice wood flooring. Neighbors are the best part of this building. People have raised multiple generations. Great for young families with first kid as there is elevator and washer dryers and many units. With larger units, can accommodate more . A great amount of storage and good lighting. Most of the facade repair seems to be completed so hopefully no need for additional construction. Cons: Property management quality has eroded over the past few years. The building is not as clean as it used to be and for a few months packages were being stolen even with security footage continuous outcry from tenants, management left blame on tenants. During a recent heat wave the power in the neighborhood went out and we effectively had to find refuge in a local grocery store. There are pests, and so you have to be diligent with using their exterminators. The windows are old and could be upgraded. No roof access. Gas stoves so you need to cook with windows open and create better ventilation. I don’t see any real outlet for the ventilation above the oven. Many of the apartments have divided the living area into a living and bedroom using a semitransparent door to allow light. This leaves limiting living space.”

— 1500 CARROLL STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Sep 2022

“Pros: Great apartment unit because it's newly renovated Lots of space Since the building is owned by a management company, there are ways to submit complaints and follow up, as well as instructions for appliances and various useful notices Really great neighborhood on the quiet side of Crown Heights Cons: Building is a pre-war building, so, although some units inside are newly renovated and great, the rest of the building isn't renovated (pipes are old, window paint peels if water leaks from rain/ice and the building is always under construction) Building is not rent stabilized, so rent raises every year Advice to landlord: renovate the rest of the building and stop raising rent. Also, stop doing construction; it's been a year and we literally don't see any changes”

— 1500 CARROLL STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Aug 2021

“Pros: Spacious rooms, and the building is kept clean. Cons: Needs a package room.”

— 1500 CARROLL STREET · Brooklyn
Advertisement