Back to 538 W 50 LLC

All 5 tenant reviews.

538 W 50 LLC · avg 3.4 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Nov 2025

“Unit 5A Pros: Pest problems have seemingly disappeared in recent years and owners are responsive. Garbage is taken out regularly Cons: There have been several water pressure issues over the years though the building usually fixes within a couple days. Communication when this happens is often delayed. Serious rat problem in basement a few years ago but haven’t seen any in about 2 years. Entryway and basement always pretty dirty but improved from recent years. Advice to landlord: More proactive communication to tenants when maintenance (planned or emergency ) occurs. More thorough cleaning of the lobby, basement, and roof common areas would go a long way”

— 536 WEST 50 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Mar 2025

“Pros: Responsive super Quiet street Cons: History of pest issues in basement (seems to have been fixed by closure of compactor) Washers and dryers poorly maintained”

— 536 WEST 50 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Jul 2023

“Pros: Elevator and laundry in the building Cons: Mice but it was resolved”

— 536 WEST 50 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Feb 2023

“Pros: Cheap to share with friends and close to many things in Hells Kitchen Cons: Huge pest issue. I did a sublease here and the place I stayed at had a history of rats. I was only there for a month and they had a nice issue there and exterminator had to come to visit. There were also mice in the laundry room. They also I Had flies everywhere in the lobby. If you’re ok with pests then maybe it will work for you. The neighbors have a ton of rats next door to them. Also living in the penthouse was a nightmare as people would be partying all night and we could hear every footstep making it a nightmare at night. Super was nice but is unresponsive as well. Advice to landlord: Be more responsive and vigilant about issues in the building. People actually live here!”

— 536 WEST 50 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Feb 2021

“Pros: The management company is responsive whenever there is an issue, it’s relatively quiet, and the people who live in the building are pleasant (with the exception one resident who constantly smokes on the first floor causing the lobby to smell like smoke) Cons: While there is laundry in the building, sometimes the washing machines are broken. This can make getting laundry done on the weekends a bit complicated. Also I wish the building was cleaned more often ( mainly the floor in the elevator and hallways). Advice to landlord: Please speak with the resident who smokes on the first floor and if possible hire a cleaning company to mop/ vacuum on a regular schedule.”

— 536 WEST 50 STREET · Manhattan
Advertisement