Back to 505 COLUMBUS LLC

All 5 tenant reviews.

505 COLUMBUS LLC · avg 2.6 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★Jun 2024

Unit 4D Pros: Great location. Minimal noise. Very active super Cons: Runs out of hot water at night when the restaurant below is closing up. Pest control does not come often

505 COLUMBUS AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★★May 2024

Unit 4F Pros: One bedroom apartment for $2500. Quiet neighbors. Great water pressure. High ceilings. Cons: Poorly maintained. Weird layout. Shares garbage room with two restaurants and the smell reaches all the way to the upper floors at times (through the door). Floors are buckling and severely slanted. Stairwell is pretty gross.

505 COLUMBUS AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★★Feb 2024

Pros: Near a grocery store and lots of food shops. The long time neighbors were better than the super. Cons: The staircase was extremely narrow and super easy to slip, which isn’t helpful if you live on the 4/5th floor. My apartment had a mouse and roach problem, but it seems like this is common for this building due to all the restaurants. The roaches weren’t tiny either, they were the giant, full sized ones that you see on the street. Thank god my cat liked killing them, but it was very hard to get rid of the mice (what we originally got the cat for due to landlord and super doing absolutely nothing, same with their exterminator, who literally just gave us glue traps). Advice to landlord: Take care of the building and upkeep

505 COLUMBUS AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★★Oct 2021

Pros: Lived in a unit facing away from the street and jt was pretty quiet, could barely hear the street. Heat was good. Was on the cheaper side compared to similar units when I rented Cons: Had mice and pests, floor boards were very damaged. Very unresponsive to the smaller issues like the toilet not working or a leaky sink. Toilet had issues and in the end we had to fix it ourselves because we got tired of waiting. Super Says someone is going to come over fix it and no one shows up at said time. Advice to landlord: Just do the things you’re supposed to do.

505 COLUMBUS AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★★Mar 2021

Pros: Location - that’s the only pro Cons: You may love this location but this building is horrible. Mice, roaches, peeling paint, smell of garbage. Landlord not responsive. Not updated. Stay away! Advice to landlord: Upgrade and clean the building. Answer the phone!

505 COLUMBUS AVENUE · Manhattan
Advertisement