Back to 48 ST. NICHOLAS LLC

All 6 tenant reviews.

48 ST. NICHOLAS LLC · avg 3.2 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Apr 2025

Pros: The super at the time was really kind and responsive. The apartment itself was nice, spacious and sunny. It was nicely painted and had new appliances as well, including laundry in unit, which was helpful. Cons: Some neighbors were so kind and community-minded. Newer neighbors were quite loud, had to move out because of incessant smoking in apartments which would fill our unit. Management support was minimal. Had mice running into the apartment as well, pest control tried to help but the issue persisted throughout our three year lease

48 ST NICHOLAS PLACE · Manhattan
★★★★Apr 2025

Pros: The building is well kept and quiet Cons: Elevator breaks often

48 ST NICHOLAS PLACE · Manhattan
★★★★Sep 2021

Pros: - quiet neighborhood - less than 3 minute walk from delis, grocery store, restaurants and train - big bedrooms and many units are renovated Cons: - delivered packages regularly stolen - laundry room often has a puddle of water on the floor - poor communication with super and property management; you will need to follow up regularly to get any requests actually done

48 ST NICHOLAS PLACE · Manhattan
★★★★Jun 2021

Pros: Lots of space, great neighbors, great neighborhood, pretty clean, great appliances, no roaches, solid and affordable laundry in basement, very few parties, nice court yard. Cons: Packages get stolen, front door is sometimes unlocked, water pressure is not great, super took a long time to respond to leaky faucet and a leaking problem. Advice to landlord: Get quicker maintenance request response times and fix the water pressure ya'll! Also: packages getting stolen is NOT something to overlook.

48 ST NICHOLAS PLACE · Manhattan
★★★★★Apr 2021

Pros: The location is near the ABCD at 145 and the apartment got lots of light. The apartment had new appliances and a nice finish. Cons: There were roaches from the day we moved in. There were a few flooding incidents. Property management was unresponsive and unhelpful. The super is very difficult to contact and does not care about how things are fixed. Advice to landlord: Listen to your tenants and address their problems.

48 ST NICHOLAS PLACE · Manhattan
★★★★★Dec 2020

Pros: Location is great. Elevator building. Unit size is great. Cons: We used to have roof access then they locked it. Super does a shoddy job of repairs and drops by unannounced so if you're not home then you're SOL for repairs. Things aren't truly repaired, it's more like they just put a temporary bandaid on the issue until it becomes a problem again. Landlord is not consistently responsive to issues. Units are overpriced. Neighbors treat the alleys like their personal backyard. Package and mail theft is an almost daily occurrence. Advice to landlord: Get a new super and become more involved. Know the community of the building. It has consistently declined over the four years I was there.

48 ST NICHOLAS PLACE · Manhattan
Advertisement