All 4 tenant reviews.

“Unit 1A Pros: Location on Manhattan. Cons: Don't expect rent receipts or a valid lease. This 9 unit townhouse apartment building is riddled with building code violations and a landlords daughter "ghosting" as the buildings Managing Agent using and abusing Power of Attorney. This building has 43 noise complaints within two years (43 police visits), no front door locks, no intercom, no laundry, no door man, illegal and unpermitted work, HP Court Actions, two Criminal Trespassing charges and one Criminal Mischief charge against the landlords daughter. https://commentariesonnyrealpropertylaw.substack.com/p/evaluating-cooperative-legitimacy Advice to landlord: Laws and building codes exist for a reason.”

“Pros: Landlord is nice, responsive, looking out for neighbors overall. Cons: There is one neighbor in the building who is a pest to everyone else. It is liveable but definitely a nuisance. Not sure he’ll be there significantly longer.”

“Pros: Still standing. Good for single individuals. Cons: No amenities such as intercom, laundry or storage. Packages stolen on a regular basis, as 452 does not have front door locks. Owners advertise some rental units as having an intercom and some with terrace but I can assure 452 never had an intercom, but should. Not the best maintained building and I don't think anyone has a valid lease. Advice to landlord: Be nice.”

“Unit 1A Pros: If you rent a courtyard facing unit you may have new/newish windows whereas renters facing street have drafty 100+ year old windows. Cons: Landlord illegally removed unsold units out of rent stabilization and gives only "subleases" or no leases. Refuses to sell unsold units to tenants past and present. Building riddled with building code violations and repairs done mostly without permits.”