All 9 tenant reviews.

“Pros: Major pro of this building is that it has in-unit washer and dryer, which is a luxury in the city. This is the biggest upside to living at 360 W 51. Cons: Persistent rodent issue. I lived here for 2 years and we had tiny mice 2-3x a year. We only ever knew because we had a cat that would chase them. In the winter, the units get extremely cold and radiators aren’t that strong. There was one winter night where there was no warm water. To make matters worse, management isn’t super responsive/friendly.”

“Unit 5A Pros: Large apartments with plenty of space Cons: Hot water boiler at least once a year, apartments get very cold during winter. Occasional mice issues.”

“Pros: Huge apartments, reasonably responsive super Cons: MAJOR mice issues that they do not address quickly”

“Pros: Was a good first apt Cons: Old and bad location”

“Unit 1A Pros: Location is fantastic and the amenities are a great convenience (new dishwasher, plus in-unit washer and dryer). Super close to restaurants and great nightlife. Living room and kitchen are massive for Manhattan and quite bright. Water pressure was GREAT - just watch out during winter since it's a very thin angle between cold water and steaming hot. Cons: German and American roaches due to painted-over rotten wood in the bathroom, even after we sealed up cracks in the bathroom/kitchen/hallway floors and windowsills. Usually saw about one roach per month (still impressive for a ground floor apartment NYC) but that was with avid cleaning, resealing, and monthly exterminating - and during a very dry year without much rain. Saw two mice during our one year inhabiting. Manageable water leak in the hallway ceiling during the spring (NOT during rain). No cause was discovered, and there's still a faint crack in the ceiling/water damage behind hallway's paint. Windows facing the street don't keep sound out at all from the front room - lots of foot traffic from the restaurants on 9th Ave, ambulance sirens, and car horns. You WILL hear the rats squeaking and getting into the trash when it's set out at the curb. Center rooms are small and dark on the lower floors. Rent going up $300 after we vacate with no updates made to the apartment ($5200 to $5500). Advice to landlord: Upgrade trash service, investigate leaks”

“Pros: Loved the super and how nice the apartment was. Beautiful kitchen. Cons: We had mice.”

“Unit 2B Pros: Great location and the apartment was large in comparison to other units in the area for the price. Water pressure was good and kitchen updated. Separate space for kitchen and living room with a nook for eating. Young crowd in the building so everyone was chill with one another and friendly. Cons: Constant mice running through the unit, when contacted they send maintenance men who barely know what they are doing and never accurately fixed the problem. They also never let you see how they were fixing it and would not try to find holes. You can tell this is an old building by the lack of updating when it comes to holes and cleanliness. You have to berate management to get them to do anything, our fridge broke and they repeatedly took forever to send someone out to help. Super never answered his phone and was useless. Advice to landlord: Clean, clean, clean and clean. Try to actually patch up holes and not do shitty work.”

“Pros: Nice trash chutes Cons: Water dripping in front of entrance”

“Pros: Fairly responsive management company, no issues with AC/heat/water. Cons: Not a clean building, people leave trash on the stairwell and recycling piles up on the first floor at the base of the stairs. Pest problems even in clean apartments (mice, cockroaches), which is probably common for the area (lots of restaurants everywhere). Advice to landlord: Make sure the exterminator actually comes every month, and keep garbage outside. Make sure cracks and holes in “renovated” apartments are properly sealed.”