Back to 321-323-325 WEST 42ND STREET LLC

All 4 tenant reviews.

321-323-325 WEST 42ND STREET LLC · avg 2.3 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Jun 2025

Pros: The apartments, themselves, are nice for the most part except the rooms are tiny (largest being 6”10 x 9”5 feet). Management is USUALLY on top of it if you submit requests via their portal. You get basically no noise if you are not street facing and maybe SOME noise if you are. It's a really safe and convenient neighborhood. The neighborhood is truly the best part. WiFi in this area is also pretty cheap ($30/600mbps). If you want to live in Lower-Mid Manhattan, this is a good deal in terms of rent, locale and convenience, but that is honestly it. But you can get something 20 times better for this rent in other locations in this city that aren't that far out. Like Williamsburg. Cons: The building is disgusting. The trash is not well kept AT ALL. There are bugs all around. We have a serious roach infestation and get massive fruit fly / gnat swarms probably once every 2-3 months. We take out trash every 2 days, have all kinds of bait and traps set up but no luck getting the roaches out. We have talked to the management about this many times too but the exterminator just sprays some shit and puts down 2 traps and dips. We see big German cockroaches.... They have constant problems with the heat and hot water. It has been on and off despite many 311 complaints. The building smells like garbage as soon as you enter. Very often, there is also garbage right outside the building door because it is Times Square BUT the problem is how poorly kept the building trash and compost is. It is always covered in flies. Advice to landlord: clean the building and respond to your tenants more often

323 WEST 42 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Jun 2024

Pros: good location, gets the job done, back facing unit quiet, nice big kitchen Cons: took long to start heat in the winter, no laundry in building and laundry is far, street is very dirty and causes stress Advice to landlord: add w/d in unit

325 WEST 42 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★May 2024

Pros: cheap for 3 bed, renovated/new units Cons: old dirty building, trash piles up at the ground floor, but it is usually taken care of

323 WEST 42 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★Nov 2020

Pros: Location to Times Square Cons: -Old Building -Old fixtures, old appliances, old everything -walk-up building -Dirty with bugs and rodents -Unsafe neighborhood Advice to landlord: Burn it Down

321 WEST 42 STREET · Manhattan
Advertisement