Back to 305 MCGUINNESS INVESTORS, LLC

All 5 tenant reviews.

305 MCGUINNESS INVESTORS, LLC · avg 3.2 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Jan 2026

“Pros: Parking, rooftop, and great location Cons: Appliances aren’t great and management is difficult to work with”

— 305 MCGUINNESS BOULEVARD · Brooklyn
★★★★★Dec 2024

“Pros: Nice place to live if you don’t mind frequent brown water and yearly rent increases. Cons: Water pressure and quality is questionable, loud street, fixtures in units are falling apart.”

— 305 MCGUINNESS BOULEVARD · Brooklyn
★★★★★May 2024

“Unit 5a Pros: Great community at the time we lived there. Cons: This rent stabilized building began to charge a 421a fee years into our lease raising our rent an additional $600 a month. Communication with management is horrific. They are totally non-responsive unless they are trying to squeeze tenants for $. They leave all maintenance up to one person who also is dealing with another property. Building has beautiful loft spaces but is terribly maintained but yet they charge more than the luxury high rises in the neighborhood. Building is located on McGuinness Blvd and is hit weekly with package left inclusive of people threatening tenants if they try and intervene yet building management refuses to put a package room in place. Advice to landlord: Needs new management and better maintenance to charge luxury prices.”

— 305 MCGUINNESS BOULEVARD · Brooklyn
★★★★★Jan 2024

“Unit 3D Pros: The apartments are spacious and decently appointed. When the windows are closed, you can barely hear the street. The roof is nice, though no public bathroom hurts. The super (as of this writing) does his best. Greenpoint, of course, is wonderful. Cons: Management is negligent. They don’t communicate with residents. They changed the door code and never told anyone; the super had to let us in. They nickel and dime everything. When appliances break, which at 20 years old, everything is starting to break, it takes months (in the case of our laundry machine, over a year) to have them fixed. McGuinness is a hellish, dangerous street. We frequently lose heat or hot water. The bathrooms are prone to mold. The garage doors break often and get stuck open, leaving the entire building (including lobby) open to the public. Package theft is a serious, frequent problem. In sum, they are wildly overcharging for this building, even by eye-watering Greenpoint standards. Advice to landlord: Find a soul and stop extorting people.”

— 305 MCGUINNESS BOULEVARD · Brooklyn
★★★★★Sep 2020

“Sadly we have had a pretty miserable experience living here. The buildings upkeep is extremely poor. Being on Mcguiness Blvd it is extremely noisy with lots of commercial traffic. Repairs sometimes take weeks. Management is not timely to reply. Unless you are getting a steal, would recommend any of the other buildings in the area off Mcguiness.”

— 305 MCGUINNESS BOULEVARD · Brooklyn
Advertisement