All 17 tenant reviews.
25TH STREET MULTIFAMILY LLC · avg 3.5 ★★★★★ · New York City
“Unit 3fe Pros: much more organized after tri hill took over great location washer dryer in all units quiet street live in super Cons: didn't have hot water for 1 month”
— 214 EAST 25 STREET · Manhattan“Pros: Apmnt is small and outdated. Good location. Nice owner Cons: Small apartment. Needs updating. Advice to landlord: Update the apartment.”
— 210 EAST 25 STREET · Manhattan“Pros: good location and I like the windows Cons: We did not have hot water from July - august 2024 and there is only a temporary fix in place. No cooking gas since July 2024 (10 months later) Stairs to basement are rotted Advice to landlord: Fix it”
— 212 EAST 25 STREET · Manhattan“Pros: Nice location and great super Cons: Hot water broke”
— 214 EAST 25 STREET · Manhattan“Unit 2 Pros: This building is in a great location, recommend for starting in New York. Well maintained, garbage is in the basement. Cons: The management was under a lawsuit while I was living there. Before I moved out, getting things done was a lot easier. We had to get a new fridge (took weeks of emails to get one) and a new dishwasher because it was invested with cockroaches. There is a pretty large bug problem and there would usually be a mouse or two each year.”
— 208 EAST 25 STREET · Manhattan“Unit 5 Pros: not much - supers are responsive Cons: the property management group should be in jail - my building has not had gas for 8 months with no signs of improvement Advice to landlord: have morals”
— 212 EAST 25 STREET · Manhattan“Pros: Amazing super, nice location Cons: Mgmt is horrible for fixes”
— 208 EAST 25 STREET · Manhattan“Pros: Nice building with laundry Cons: Landlord doesn’t fix broken things Advice to landlord: Fix broken things”
— 214 EAST 25 STREET · Manhattan“Pros: Great live in super, no pests Cons: Washer, dryer, dishwasher were unbelievably disgusting when I moved in and throughout my stay. Advice to landlord: Please clean or replace your appliances”
— 210 EAST 25 STREET · Manhattan“Unit LE Pros: Apartments are remodeled inside and modern Washer and dryer in unit Dishwasher Cons: Building is old and falling apart Mice/rats run through the walls and ceiling and in the hallways Apartment has roaches Advice to landlord: Redo the ceiling and hallways of the buildings so mice and rats can’t come and go and keep up with exterminator”
— 212 EAST 25 STREET · Manhattan“Pros: Close to grocery stores, restaurants, and subway lines. Overall safe neighborhood. Amazing live-in supers who are responsive and always willing to help. Cons: There was an on-going cockroach problem coming into the building and the units. The stove would constantly break and management would take a long time to respond to our messages to try and fix the issue. The neighbors downstairs were loud and would watch tv early in the morning with the volume up. The heat would also be on really high; our windows were open during the winter. No exhaust in the kitchen so our apartment would smoke up and have the fire alarm go off often. Advice to landlord: Add vents to the kitchen and bathroom. Address tenant issues quickly.”
— 208 EAST 25 STREET · Manhattan“Pros: amazing live in super, pest control is monthly and decent, in unit washer and dryers, balconies in certain units, clean hallways, good location Cons: Tenants received multiple letters that the management was in default of their mortgage and didn’t explain to the tenants what that meant for them, extreme rent increases at renewal, people go door to door to protest landlord and ask for tenant support as landlord has been in prison for tenant related offenses and finance issues, when it rains the roof leaks Advice to landlord: Respect tenants, fix roofing issues”
— 214 EAST 25 STREET · Manhattan“Pros: Cheap, great live-in super, great location, clean hallways, mailboxes, etc. Cons: Bad garbage management leads to a ton of mice running around the back alley and the front of the building. Advice to landlord: Better system for trash management”
— 214 EAST 25 STREET · Manhattan“Pros: Back patios and balconies are great Cons: Mice and roaches in building”
— 208 EAST 25 STREET · Manhattan“Pros: Units are renovated/maintained, with relatively new fixtures and appliances. Bathroom is spacious, with a good shower. In-unit w/d is nice, though they are SMALL and the dryer isn’t the best. Cons: UPDATE 2023: look up Steve Croman and Centennial Properties before signing ANYTHING. This company is embroiled in law suits. Tenants have been sending their rent to a law firm since August 2022 because the company is engaged in illegal business practices. The super scams new tenants out of $130 by uninstalling padlocks prior to move-in (leaving an open hole in the front door), then insisting that new tenants pay cash under the table to have a “new” padlock installed (he reinstalls the one he removed between tenants). Definitely not paying for space, as the bedroom is cramped and there isn’t much counter space in the kitchen(ette) area. Also, in-unit w/d sounds nice in theory, but the washer is super small, and the dryer is either so hot it shrinks everything, or so mild that it doesn’t fully dry. Also the super is only responsive when you submit a ticket through the property management site. Don’t let him bully you into working with him directly, he is shady as noted above, plus pretends to be responsive then never actually solves issues (unless there’s documentation with the property management company). Advice to landlord: Tell the super to stop trying to cut property management out of tenant interactions. He routinely bullies tenants into working with him directly, and it’s not great.”
— 208 EAST 25 STREET · Manhattan“Pros: Great location, stairs leading to units are cute Cons: Would be nice if it had an elevator but this is NYC”
— 214 EAST 25 STREET · Manhattan“Pros: Great super in building Cons: Basement level units”
— 210 EAST 25 STREET · Manhattan