Back to 255 WEST 75TH STREET,

All 6 tenant reviews.

255 WEST 75TH STREET, · avg 2.8 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Oct 2025

“Pros: Neighborhood; liked the super Cons: apartment was in pretty bad condition, including mold and and water damage Advice to landlord: invest in maintaining units and building”

— 255 WEST 75 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Jun 2024

“Unit 2F Pros: Very friendly/responsive super. Great neighborhood. Friendly neighbors Cons: Some pest/cockroach issues. Heat/hot water cuts out frequently in the winter. Thin floors/ceilings.”

— 255 WEST 75 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Nov 2023

“Pros: Great location, water pressure is good, elevator and laundry in building Cons: Building smells bad and frequently has flies and roaches. Units are small, dark, and outdated. Garbage is frequently left at the bottom of stairwell. There was a persistent fly issue in the building, I complained to the property manager Angela Cronk who responded that she had gone to the building and not seen any flies. I escalated and complained to 311 and upon their inspection, they issued a violation for the fly infestation. That should tell you all your need to know about the management of this building. Would not recommend.”

— 255 WEST 75 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★May 2022

“Pros: Not too expensive, decent sized apartment for the price. Cons: Construction outside which wouldn't be a problem except that the windows block no noise. Packages are often stolen and the other month a homeless person got into the building and shit in the stairwell.”

— 255 WEST 75 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Feb 2022

“Pros: - Good location near 72nd St station, grocery stores, parks, bars and restaurants - Reasonable prices Cons: - Persistent pest issues (mice and cockroaches) - Issues with heat given age of the building - Issues with elevator and buzzer system not working - Management seems generally indifferent to the state of the building, the complaints of tenants, etc Advice to landlord: More focus on the upkeep of the building would probably go a long way in fixing some of the persistent issues (pests, heating issues, buzzer, etc). More of a focus on cleanliness would be great.”

— 255 WEST 75 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Jan 2022

“Pros: Quiet area. Nice location. Nice units Cons: Brusco is impossible to find”

— 255 WEST 75 STREET · Manhattan
Advertisement