Back to 254 MENAHAN LLC

All 6 tenant reviews.

254 MENAHAN LLC · avg 4.0 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Sep 2025

“Pros: -Very responsible landlord -Basement storage -Modern kitchen and big living room Cons: -Zero natural light -No recycling or composing -Illegal activity in the building”

— 254 MENAHAN STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Jun 2023

“Pros: love that the building was really old had a lot of character Cons: serious need of rat abatement Advice to landlord: none!”

— 254 MENAHAN STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Jul 2022

“Pros: Nice building, only 3 units, responsive landlord. Cons: Appliances are old and outdated and rent continues to rise despite no improvements being made. Heard rats in the walls in my last few months there but never saw them....”

— 254 MENAHAN STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Jul 2022

“Unit 1 Pros: Great location, recently added amenities (washer/dryer in basement + storage lockers). Nice backyard if you live on 1st floor. Owner / management was very responsive for the few issues we've had. Cons: The radiators don't heat the 1st floor very evenly likely due to bad window insulation in the back of the building. The back rooms required space heaters during the winter. Advice to landlord: Improve the insulation / heating in the back of the building.”

— 254 MENAHAN STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Oct 2021

“Pros: Location, size of living space, 2 bathrooms Cons: Trains and traffic can get very loud.”

— 254 MENAHAN STREET · Brooklyn
★★★★★Feb 2021

“Pros: The landlord is responsive and neighbors are quiet and like to keep it that way Cons: A bit expensive Advice to landlord: Bro, it’s Covid season and refusing to negotiate the price is a bit strange.”

— 254 MENAHAN STREET · Brooklyn
Advertisement