Back to 234 W 21ST ST OWNRS C

All 5 tenant reviews.

234 W 21ST ST OWNRS C · avg 4.0 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Dec 2025

“Pros: - friendly neighbors - great location, close to transit - beautiful old building Cons: - unresponsive building management - poorly heated in the winter months - frequent package theft Advice to landlord: Building needs to be run by professionals”

— 234 WEST 21 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Jul 2025

“Pros: Clean. Kind neighbors. Beautiful sunlight. Good layouts. Cons: Slow to act on things like broken windows.”

— 234 WEST 21 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★May 2023

“Pros: Cute building, great neighbors and super, close to a Walgreens and subway station Cons: There are water bugs in the lower apartments, not a great spot for a good supermarket or deli with a vast array of necessities. At night, 6th gets very dicey. There are often issues with people staying in the walkway and police are called every two months or so because of it to remove them.”

— 234 WEST 21 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Aug 2022

“Pros: For being so close to so much, it’s a very quiet and green block. It’s a nice pre-war building, and the buzzer system is good. The tenants seem like a mix of friendly single older people who have been in the neighborhood for a while and yuppies who are not as friendly. Laundry room is never busy. Cons: The elevator is slow. Our unit doesn’t have great light and feels claustrophobic sometimes. We found one cockroach once but never saw any more. Advice to landlord: I think they’re doing a great job, just maybe adding a few garbage and recycling bins so they don’t get as full.”

— 234 WEST 21 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Jan 2022

“Pros: Building is quiet, clean and a great place to live. Cons: Last year the gas was off for several months, landlords where super friendly and apologetic, going as far as to discount the rent and provide us with electric stove tops and an electric mini oven but it took several months of back and forth with PG&E to resolve. Advice to landlord: None, thank you!”

— 234 WEST 21 STREET · Manhattan
Advertisement