Back to 195 UNDERHILL LLC

All 7 tenant reviews.

195 UNDERHILL LLC · avg 3.1 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Nov 2025

“Unit 2a Pros: Great location, amazing super, responsive management and good price for the neighborhood Cons: We had some pest issues for awhile, but to be fair management was responsive and offered extermination services”

— 195 UNDERHILL AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Jul 2025

“Unit 3C Pros: Amazing location and price (for some units) Cons: Slumlord management who didn't care that our building was falling apart Advice to landlord: Be less evil”

— 195 UNDERHILL AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Apr 2025

“Unit 2J Pros: Pre-war building, neighbors are generally friendly, generally quiet building, maintenance/super is very responsive and helpful , neighborhood and location are great Cons: 1 bedroom units are expensive for how small they are, building management company appears disorganized, trash and recycles can pile up at times, MAJOR roach issues during the summer, building is infested and managements only solution is monthly spraying by exterminator company, this was only a temporary fix.”

— 195 UNDERHILL AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Jul 2024

“Pros: Location, that's about it. Cons: PESTS, bad responsiveness from owners, supers are incredible and neighbors are kind”

— 195 UNDERHILL AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Apr 2023

“Pros: Quiet area and friendly neighbors Cons: Huge Roach Infestation”

— 195 UNDERHILL AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Apr 2021

“Pros: Rent stabilized, owner/management is responsive Cons: Studios are tiny. Roaches throughout building. No regular extermination. Apartment was not clean upon move-in Advice to landlord: Hire bimonthly extermination and actually clean your vacant units before move in.”

— 195 UNDERHILL AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Mar 2021

“Pros: Great location, rent stabilized, quiet, well maintained. Cons: Not a lot of cons but I’d beware because this building just got purchased from long time local owners. Beware if the rents are high and the apartments have been gut renovated. I’d look up your rental history from NY DHCR and file a formal complaint because you may be overpaying. Advice to landlord: Just be responsive and kind to your tenants even if they’re not paying market rate. Be good communicators and respect them.”

— 195 UNDERHILL AVENUE · Brooklyn
Advertisement