Back to 184 FIRST REALTY

All 4 tenant reviews.

184 FIRST REALTY · avg 2.5 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Mar 2024

“Pros: Heart of the East Village Cons: Crazy Street Corner Bad Management Tons of Noise! No sleep! Advice to landlord: Clean up the area/ground floor tenants and it would be much better!”

— 184 1 AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★★Jun 2023

“Unit 1A Pros: Somewhat large unit for the area Cons: Railroad style unit, someone broke into the apartment on our floor in broad daylight, packages were constantly stolen, Sahara East would play music so loud that the floor would shake until 2am on the weekdays, unresponsive landlord Advice to landlord: Actually address renter's concerns instead of ingoring them”

— 184 1 AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★★Aug 2022

“Pros: Responsive Super, no functional problems Cons: Mice and Cockroaches, directly above extremely loud bar”

— 184 1 AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★★Dec 2021

“Pros: If you go to nyu and are upper class this place will work for you. No bugs, no major maintenance issues, and super is very consistent about taking out trash. Cons: The leasing company is SO shady!! They only allow paper transaction and do not even have an email address or a website you can contact them at. Make sure to keep ALL receipts for rent checks - once they said we owed 3k when we most definitely did NOT, and had to call back and forth to get it cleared up once we proved we had the receipt for a check written for that month. Additionally, for a half month of rent the leasing company gave us the WRONG amount of what we owed, and we had to correct that. Additionally, consider investing in a PO Box and or FedEx holding service for your packages if you live here. Within 6 months, had five packages stolen and the super is not interested in helping. Advice to landlord: Install a camera in the lobby! Or just in the entry! Me and my fellow residents’ packages are consistently stolen!!!”

— 184 1 AVENUE · Manhattan
Advertisement