All 14 tenant reviews.

“Pros: Great amenities, responsive staff Cons: ceilings are low, not enough light”

“Unit 834 Pros: The Caledonia is a well maintained building in a great location in West Chelsea. We've really enjoyed all of the building staff - they are incredibly friendly and helpful. They even offer package delivery to your unit, for example. Another great benefit is that there is an Equinox gym in the retail level of the building with a private elevator for building residents and discounted monthly memberships. Cons: Our unit is South facing the Chelsea Market, so there is not a lot of natural light in the unit. Also, there are some things that a little bit outdated in the unit for being a luxury building, such as the bathroom sink and kitchen finishes. Overall, the cons of the building is that you are paying a premium rent due to the location and could probably get more value elsehwere.”

“Pros: Amazing management, very clean, quiet, great amenities. Cons: Very Expensive, sometimes a lot of tourists by Chelsea market. The renters roof room has been unavailable for the past few months. The working spaces / printer are nice to have but I don't use since there arent windows.”

“Pros: - Great common areas - Roof deck with sun all day - Quiet building - Helpful front desk staff - Apartments with high ceilings, large windows, nice finishes - Very responsive & helpful maintenance staff - Equinox in building Cons: - Sometimes hard to get in touch with building management / leasing office - Lax security from front desk staff - Poor maintenance of common areas - A/Cs are bulky & loud - Renting party room is so expensive - Building just keeps getting more & more expensive”

“Pros: Beautiful building & great, spacious apartments Nice amenities (rooftop, common room, business room, garden) Cons: Bad service for the price of monthly fees Concierge loose packages, building is so big that they have trouble keeping up Doorpeople do not open door Bad block, surrounded by projects Attached to highline but no access to highline from building So many people that you are always in the elevator with delivery people Advice to landlord: Too much turnover with workers, get some consistent workers to help with the service, get rid of doorpeople if they are not going to open door”

“Pros: New, quiet, views Cons: Expensive, mainly rental building”

“Pros: Beautiful building, great location, helpful staff Cons: They just implemented a regime of fines for all sorts of things in the building with no description of how people will be deemed in violation of rules or what an appeals process would be. Advice to landlord: Get a life”

“Pros: Location, very helpful management, equinox in building Cons: Street noise, small rooftop”

“Unit 334 Pros: Most Staff very nice..clean and safe Cons: Staff (Judy) shouldn’t be at front desk during day .. she needs to be there overnight when not so much traffic can’t multitask keep her on the doors ..kind rude to dumb to know it Advice to landlord: Don’t put staff in areas where they are not suitable for”

“Pros: Management was responsive, beautiful common spaces, great location Cons: Neighbors were inconsiderate”

“Unit 1903 Pros: I have only positive things to say about the Caledonia, the lobby is super nice, the doormen are friendly and helpful, and the amenities are good Cons: The business centers are a little small, but otherwise then building amenities are great”

“Pros: Beautiful luxury buildings Cons: Some of the other tenants are openly racist. Very small apartments You have to pay extra for everything “included” in the building including the garage”

“Pros: Well maintained luxury building with friendly lobby staff Cons: Very noisy on the 10th ave side. Leasing office staff will lie to your face. Advice to landlord: Sound proof the windows”

“Pros: Location, Build Staff Cons: Very Small apartments Advice to landlord: I do not have any advice”