Back to 1734 AMSTERDAM PARTNERS LLC

All 3 tenant reviews.

1734 AMSTERDAM PARTNERS LLC · avg 3.0 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Jun 2025

“Pros: Loved the layout and light in the apartment Cons: Management was frequently misleading, did not resolve serious issues in a timely manner, and clearly said contradicting things to different neighbors. There’s issues with the boiler and every year the heat turning on or off is a whole ordeal. Advice to landlord: Empower your management to actually fix the issues of this building, especially the boiler.”

— 1734 AMSTERDAM AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★★Feb 2022

“Pros: Great location, natural light, closet space, nice layout, lovely neighbors, thick walls/floors for privacy Cons: It's an old building that clearly has problems and management can be incredibly difficult about solving them. Heat/hot water was a recurring issue. It went out every couple of weeks, at least. Trash was also not managed well and and the "virtual doorman" frequently broke down. There were no major pest issues for most of our time there, although the number of roaches was increasing towards the end of our lease. The major issue was that management was unresponsive and unreliable. They regularly lied about maintenance issues and refused to offer lease renewals to tenants who complained about illegal conditions.”

— 1734 AMSTERDAM AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★★Jan 2021

“Pros: Gorgeous building, virtual doorperson, great neighborhood Cons: Noisy intersection and no elevator Advice to landlord: It would be helpful if the heat was working”

— 1734 AMSTERDAM AVENUE · Manhattan
Advertisement